The general historians who deal with the period—Hume, Robertson, Tytler, Laing, Froude, and Hill Burton—are usually ranked among Queen Mary's opponents. Hume and Froude occupy the most decided position. Among other writers who are definitely against the theory of Mary's innocence, must be reckoned Mignet ("Life of Mary Queen of Scots"), Mr. D. Hay Fleming ("Mary Queen of Scots"), and Mr. T. F. Henderson (articles, "Mary Stuart," "Henry Stewart, Lord Darnley," "James Hepburn, Earl of Bothwell," &c., in the Dictionary of National Biography). No one can hope to understand the present position of the controversy without the writings of Mr. Fleming and Mr. Henderson. Among general controversialists on the side of Queen Mary, may be mentioned the works already quoted, by Walter Goodall, George Chalmers, and John Hosack, William Tytler's "Inquiry into the Evidence against Mary Queen of Scots" (1790), Whitaker's "Mary Queen The last few years have seen the publication of many important works dealing with the problem of the Casket Letters, e.g.:— Bresslau: "Die Kassettenbriefe der KÖnigin Maria Stuart," in the Historisches Taschenbuche, 1882. Sepp: Die Kassettenbriefe, 1884. Gerde: "Geschichte der KÖnigin Maria Stuart," 1885. T. F. Henderson: "Casket Letters, and Mary Queen of Scots." 2nd ed. 1890. Philippson: "Histoire du RÈgne de Marie Stuart," 1891-92. The English reader will find the material in Mr. T. F. Henderson's work ample for his purpose. The preface to Mr. Hay Fleming's "Mary Queen, of Scots" promises a second volume, which will contain the life in captivity, and, of course, deal with the letters. No Marian apologist has, as yet, attempted an answer to the more recent evidence on the other side, and Hosack's great work is now considerably superseded. The foregoing lists are, of course, selected. A full Bibliography is a great task, not yet attempted. THE ENDFootnotesE. = English; F.= Published French; L. = Latin. L. "Item cur venisrem? an reconciliationis causa? ac nominatim, an tu hic esses? An familiÆ catalogum fecissem? An Paridem et Gilbertum acceptissem, qui mihi scriberent? an Josephum dimissura essem?" F. "Item pour quoy j'estoye venue, et si c'estoit pour faire une reconciliation; si vous estiez icy; et si j'avoye faict quelque rolle de mes domestiques; si j'avois prins Paris et Gilbert, afin qu'ils m'escrivissent; et si je ne vouloye pas licentier Joseph." E. "Lord of Lusse." L. "Lussae Comarchus." F. "Le prevost de Lusse." {J'ay bien la vogue avec vous P. F. = Published French; L.= Latin. The English translation at Hatfield follows the Hatfield French version closely. The two most important passages run thus: "Otherwise, Printed by Ballantyne, Hanson & Co. Edinburgh & London Published by David Nutt, 270-271 Strand, London, and Sold by all Booksellers throughout Scotland, England, and Ireland. SCOTTISH VERNACULAR LITERATURE A Succinct History By T. F. HENDERSON Printed at the Constable Press, 1898 Crown 8vo, x, 464 pp. Buckram, top gilt, 6s. Contents:—The Scottish Vernacular—Minstrelsy and Romance—Historical Poetry—The Scottish Fabliau and the Decay of Romance—The Early Chaucerians—Dunbar and Walter Kennedy—Gavin Douglas and Sir David Lyndsay—Minor and Later Poets of the 16th Century—Anonymous Poetry of the 15th and 16th Centuries—Vernacular Prose—Traditional Ballads and Songs—Before Ramsay—Ramsay to Burns—Burns and afterwards. Some Press NoticesOutlook.—"Truly admirable for its conciseness and adequacy of critical treatment." Literature.—"A work of great merit and interest, and unique in its field." Scotsman.—"Will be of great use to those who wish a general guide to Scottish literature in prose, such as there was, as well as in verse." North British Daily Mail.—"A model of what such a handbook should be—thorough, concise, well balanced." Saturday Review.—"Excellent in every respect." Morning Post.—"It is not easy to recall another volume, conceived on this apparently unambitious scale, which is at once so scholarly, so thorough, so agreeable." Glasgow Herald.—"Deserves a hearty welcome and no stintedpraise." Arbroath Herald.—"Few readers will fail to appreciate the justice and the suggestive force of his general survey of Scottish literature." Transcribers NoteHeadings printed at the top of pages in the original have been converted to sub-headings and placed and the head of the most relevant paragraph - see grey shaded sub-headings Much of the text being letters and transcripts, inconsistant spellings have been retained Footnote 64 had no anchor in the text. Since it appears to relate to the whole of letter III an anchor has been inserted at to top of the letter. |