Footnotes.

Previous

Dowling, “Introduction to Study of Eccl. Hist.; its Progress and Sources.” Lond.,1838.

Smedt, “Introd. generalis ad Hist. Eccl. critice tractandam.” Gandavi,1876.

2

See Sermon on The Pharisees in Mozley’s “Univ. Sermons.” Lond.,1876; also

SchÜrer, Div.II., vol.ii., pp.1-43, “Pharisees and Sadducees.”

3

See Lightfoot, Ep. to the Col., 5thed., Lond.,1880, Diss. on “Essenes, their Name, Origin, and Relation to Christianity.” pp.349-419; also

SchÜrer, Div.II., vol.ii., pp.188-218, “The Essenes.”

4

Nutt, Sketch of Samaritan History, Dogma, and Literature. Lond.,1874.

5

On Philo, see SchÜrer, Div.II., vol.iii., pp.321-381.

6

J. Bannerman, “The Church of Christ.” 2vols., Edin.,1868.

Jacob, “Ecclesiastical Polity of the New Testament.” Lond.,1871.

Hatch, “The Organization of the Early Chr. Churches.” Lond.,1881; 2nded.,1883.

D. D. Bannerman, “The Doctrine of the Church.” Edin.,1887.

Hodge, “The Church and its Polity.” Edin.,1879.

Binnie, “The Church.” Edin.,1882.

PressensÉ, “Life and Pract. of Early Church.” Lond.,1879.

Lightfoot, “Comm. on Philip.” “Essay on Christian Ministry.” 6thed., Lond.,1881, pp.181-269.

7

Mommsen, “De collegiis et sodaliciis Rom.” Kiel,1843.

Foucart, “Les associat. relig. chez les Grecs.” Paris,1873.

Hatch, “Organization of Early Chr. Churches.” pp.26-39.

8

Lightfoot, “Epistle to Phil.” 6thed., Lond.,1881, p.95. Detached notes on the synonyms “bishop” and “presbyter.” “Diss. on Christian Ministry.” pp.187-200.

9

Blondel, “Apologia pro sententia Hieron. de episcop. et presbyt.” Amst.,1646.

10

The f???a ????? of Rom. xvi.16; 1Cor. xvi.20.

11

Of these we probably find fragments in Eph.ii.14; 1Tim. iii.16; 2Tim. ii.11-13; and perhaps also in 1Tim. iii.1,16; Jas.i.17; Rev.i.4; iv.11; v.9; xi.15; xv.3; xxi.1; xxii.10.

12

Acts ii.4,6; xx.7.

13

John xx.26; Acts xx.7; 1Cor. xvi.2; Rev.i.10.

14

Acts ii.39; xvi.33; 1Cor.vii.14.

15

Acts viii.17; vi.6; xiii.3; 1Tim.iv.14.

16

On the subject of this section consult:

PressensÉ, “Early Years of Christianity.” Vol.2, “Apostolic Age.” Lond.,1879, pp.361-381.

Lechler, “Apostolic and Post Apostolic Times.” 2vols., Edin.,1886; Vol.i., pp.37-67, 130-144.

17

Burton, “Heresies of the Apostolic Age.” Oxford,1829.

18

As authorities for this period consult:

Moshemii, “Commentarii de reb. Christianor. ante Constant.” Helmst.,1753.

Baur, “First Three Centuries of the Christian Church.” Lond.,1877.

Milman, “Hist. of Chr. to Abol. of Pag. in Rom. Emp.” 3vols., Lond.,1840.

PressensÉ, “Early Years of Christianity.” 4vols., Lond.,1879.

19

Consult:

Killen, “The Ancient Church.” Edin.,1859; “The Old Catholic Church.” Edin.,1871.

Lechler, “Apost. and Post-Apost. Times.” 2vols., Edin.,1886; Vol.ii., pp.260-379.

Robertson, “Hist. of Chr. Church.” Vol.i., (A.D.64-590), Lond.,1858.

20 Although the Post-Apostolic and Old Catholic Ages are sharply enough distinguished from one another in point of time and of contents along many lines of historical development, and are rightly partitioned off from each other, so that they might seem to require treatment as independent periods; yet, on the one hand, passing over from the one to the other is so frequent and is for the most part of so liquid and incontrollable a nature, while on the other hand, the opposition of and the distinction between these two periods and the oecumenical Catholic Imperial Church that succeeds are so thorough-going, that we prefer to embrace the two under one period and to point out the boundary lines between the two wherever these are clearly discernible.
21

Inge, “Society in Rome under the CÆsars.” Lond.,1887.

22

Uhlhorn, “Conflict of Christianity with Heathenism.”

Steere, “Account of the Persecutions of the Church under the Roman Emperors.”

23

Renan, “Antichrist.” Lond.,1874.

Merivale, “Hist. of Rom. Emp.” Vols.v.vi., Lond.,1856,1858.

Farrar’s “Early Days of Christianity.” Lond.,1884; Bk.I., pp.1-44.

Mommsen, “Hist. of Rome.” 6vols., Lond.,1875ff.

24

Renan, “Marcus Aurelius.” Lond.,1883.

Lightfoot, “Ignatius and Polycarp.” 3vols., Lond.,1885.

25

Lightfoot, “Ignatius.” Vol.i., pp.469-476.

26

“Kirchengesch. v. Dtschl.” I.94.

27

Mason, “The Persecution of Diocletian.” Cambridge,1876.

28

Cotterill, “Peregrinus Proteus.” Edin.,1879; Engl. Transl. of Lucian’s works, by Dr.Francklin, 4vols., Lond.,1781.

29

Baur, “Christian Church in First Three Centuries.” Lond.,1877.

“Celsus and Origen.” in vol.iv. of Froude’s “Short Studies.”

30

Philostratus, “Life of Apollonius of Tyana.” First 2bks., Transl. by Blount, Lond.,1680.

Newman, “Hist. Sketches.” Vol.i., chap.ii., “Apollonius of Tyana.”

31

The works of Plotinus consist of 54 treatises arranged in 6Enneads, “Opera Omnia.” ed.Creuzer, 3vols., Oxon.,1835. Several of the treatises transl. into English by H.Taylor, Lond.,1794 and1817.

32

Zeller, “History of Eclecticism in Greek Philosophy.” Lond.,1831.

Ueberweg, “Hist. of Phil.” Lond.,1872; Vol.i., pp.240-252.

33

“Narratio orig. rituum et error. Christianor. S.Joannis.” Rom.,1652.

34

Ewald, “Hist. of Israel.” Lond.,1886; Vol.viii., p.120.

35

In de Sacy’s “Chrestom. Arabe.” 2ed., I.333.

36

1Cor. xvi.3; 2Cor. viii.19; Gal.ii.9.

37

Burton, “Heresies of the Apostolic Age.” Oxford,1829.

Zeller, “Acts of the Apostles.” 2vols., London, 1875,1876.

PressensÉ, “Apostolic Age.” London,1879, pp.66-73; 318-330.

38

Neander’s “First Planting of Christianity and Antignostikus.” (Bohn), 2vols., Lond.,1851.

Mansel, “Gnostic Heresies of First and Second Centuries.” Ed.by Bishop Lightfoot, Lond.,1875.

King, “Remains of the Gnostics.” Lond.,1864; new ed.,1887.

Ueberweg, “Hist. of Phil.” 2vols., Lond.,1872, Vol.i., pp.280-290.

39

These are published among the works of Origen. Recently Caspari discovered an admirable Latin translation of them made by Rufinus, and published it in his “Kirchenhist. Anecdota.”I., (Christ.,1883).

40

Lipsius, “Valentinus and his School.” in Smith’s “Dict. of Biography.” Vol.iv., Lond.,1887.

41

In Cureton’s “Spicil. Syr.” Lond.,1855.

42

In its extant Coptic form, ed. by Petermann, Brl., 1851.

In a Latin transl. by Schwartze, Brl., 1853.

In English transl. in King’s “Remains of the Gnostics.” Lond., 1887.

43

Yet the school of Baur regard this Gospel of Marcion as the original of Luke. Hilgenfeld thinks that both our Luke and Marcion drew from one earlier source. Hahn has sought to restore the Marcionite Gospel in Thilo’s “Cod. Apoc. N.T.” I.401.

Sanday, “Gospels in the Second Century.” London,1876.

44

Salmon, “Introd. to the N.T.” London,1885, pp.242-248.

Reuss, “Hist. of N.T.” Edin.,1884, §§291, 246, 362,508.

45

Lightfoot, “Comm. on Galatians.” Camb.,1865; Diss. “St.Paul and the Three.”

46

Lechler, “Apost. and Post-Apostol. Times.” Vol.ii., p.263ff.

Ewald, “Hist. of Israel.” Lond.,1886, Vol.viii., p.152.

47

Ewald, “Hist. of Israel.” Vol.viii., p.122.

48

We possess this work in the original Greek. The first complete edition was that of Cotelerius in his “Pp.Apost.” The latest and most careful separate ed., is by Lagarde, Lps.,1865; Eng. transl. in Ante Nicene Lib., Edin.,1871.

49

Existing only in the Latin transl. of Rufinus. Published in Cotelerius, “Pp.Apost.”

Separate ed. by Gersdorf, Lps.,1838; Eng. transl. Ante-Nicene Lib., Edin.,1867.

50

See de Sacy, “Mem. sur diverses antiqu. de la Perse.” Par.,1794.

The most important of these Arabic works are the Literary History of An-Naddim, Kitab al Fihrist, ed.FlÜgel and Roediger, Lps.,1871; then

Al-Shurstani’s “Hist. of relig. and phil. sects.” ed.Cureton, Lond.,1842; and

Al-Biruni’s “Chron. d. Orient VÖlker.” ed.Sachau, Lps.,1878.

51

Among the Mandeans mana rabba means one of the highest Æons, and is thus perhaps identical with the name Paraclete borrowed from the Christian terminology, which Manes assumed.

52

Ueberweg, “Hist. of Phil.” 2vols., Lond.,1872, Vol.i., pp.290-325. Patristic. Phil. down to Council of NicÆa.

53

Donaldson, “Apostolic Fathers.” Lond.,1874.

Lightfoot, “Clement of Rome.” 2vols., Lond., 1869, 1877; Ignatius and Polycarp, 3vols., Lond.,1885.

Sanday, “The Gospels in the Second Century.” Lond.,1876.

54

Luke i.1; §32,4; 36,7; 59,1.

55

“Patrum Apost. Opera.” Ed. Gebhardt, Harnack and Zahn, 3vols., Lps.,1876ff.

“Apostolic Fathers.” Engl. transl. in Ante-Nicene Library, Edin.,1867.

Donaldson, “Apostolic Fathers.” Edin.,1874.

56

At Constantinople, 1875.

57

Comp. Lightfoot, “St.Clement of Rome, An Appendix.” etc., Lond.,1877.

58

Donaldson, “History of Christian Literature.” Vol.i., Lond.,1864.

Cunningham, “Dissertation on Epistle of St.Barnabas.” Lond.,1877.

59

“HermÆ Pastor.” ed. Hilgenfeld, 2ed., Lps.,1881. Down to the middle of the 19th century it was known only in a Latin translation, but since then the Greek original has been accessible in two recensions, as well as in an ancient Ethiopic translation (ed.d’Abbadie, Lps.,1860). One of the Greek recensions almost complete was found in the monastery of Athos; and an older, but less perfect one, was found in the Codex Sinaiticus.

Schodde, “Herm NabÎ; The Ethiopic version of Pastor HermÆ examined.” Lps.,1876.

60

Comp.

Harnack in Expositor for March,1886, pp.185-192.

Lightfoot, “Ignatius and Polycarp.” Lond.,1885, vol.ii., pp.433-470.

61

Cureton, “Corpus Ignatianum.” (Rom., Eph., and Ep. to Polyc.), Lond.,1819.

62

Against their genuineness:

DallÆus, “De scrr. quÆ sub Dionysii et Ignatii nom. circumfer.” Gen.,1666.

Killen, “Ignatian Epistles entirely Spurious.” Edin.,1886.

In favour:

Pearson, “VindiciÆ St. Ignat.” Cantab.,1672.

Lightfoot, “Ignatius and Polycarp.” 3vols., Lond.,1885.

63

Salmon, “Introd. to the New Testament.” Lond.,1885, pp.104-126.

Sanday, “Gospels in Second Century.” Lond.,1876.

64

Schaff, “The Oldest Church Manual.” Edin.,1886.

Hitchcock and Brown, “Teaching of the Twelve Apostles.” New York,1884.

Taylor, “The Teaching of the Twelve Apostles with Illus. from the Talmud.” Cambr.,1886.

Expositor, April and June,1886, pp.319f. and 401ff.; Nov.,1887, pp.359-371.

65

Donaldson, “Hist. of Chr. Lit. from death of App. to Nic. Council.” 3vols., Lond.,1864, Vols.ii. andiii., “The Apologists.”

66

The Syriac translation of a treatise of Melito’s given in Cureton’s “Spicileg. Syr.” Lond.,1853, which gives itself out as an address delivered before Antoninus CÆsar, is not identical with his Apology to Antoninus Pius, of which Eusebius has preserved three fragments, as these passages are not found init.

67

The fragments of Melito’s works are collected by Routh, “ReliquiÆ Sacr.”L., Oxon.,1814.

68

“Opera.” ed. Otto, 3vols., Jena,1876; Engl. transl. in Ante-Nicene Library, Edin.,1867.

Semisch, “Just. Mart.” 2vols., Edin.,1843.

Kaye, “Writings and Opin. of Just. Mart.” Lond.,1853.

69

Salmon, “Introd. to New Test.” On Tatian, pp.96-104.

Wace on “Zahn’s Tatian’s Diatessaron.” in Expositor for Sept. and Oct.,1882.

70

Bigg, “The Christian Platonists of Alexandria.” Bampton Lect. for1886, Oxf.,1886.

Kingsley, “Alexandria and her Schools.” Camb.,1854.

71

“Opera.” ed. Harvey, Cantab.,1857; Introd.II.

“Life and Wr. of IrenÆus.” Engl. transl. in Ante-Nicene Lib., 2vols., Edin., 1868,1869.

Lightfoot, “Churches of Gaul.” in Contemp. Review, Aug.1876.

Lipsius, “IrenÆus.” in Smith’s “Dict. of Chr. Biog.”III., pp.253-279.

72

Many works ascribed to him have been lost; whatever fragments of these exist have been collected by Fabricius and Lagarde. These were:

Exeget., a Com. on Daniel;

Apolog., ???? ???da????;

Polem.,

against Gnostics and Monarchians,

against the Asiatic Observance of Easter (§37,2);

Dogmat.,

?e?? t?? t?? p??t?? ??s?a?,

?e?? t?? ??t????st??,

?e?? t?? ??ast?se?? (§22,4),

?e?? ?a??s?t??;

Hist.-chron., Chronicle, and Easter-Canon.

On Philosophoumena:

DÖllinger, “Hippolytus and Callistus.” Edin.,1876.

73

“Opera.” ed. Dindorf, 4vols., Oxon.,1868.

“Supplementum Clementinum, in Zahn’s Forsch.” Vol.iii., Engl. transl. in Ante-Nicene Lib., 2vols., Edin.,1867.

Bigg, “Chr. Plat. of Alex.” Lectt.II.III., Oxf.,1886.

Kaye, “Clement of Alexandria.” London,1855.

Reuss, “Hist of Canon.” Edin.,1884, pp.112-116.

74

Jerome reckons them at2,000; Epiphanius at6,000; these must include the thousands of separate epistles and homilies.

Bigg, “Chr. Platonists of Alex.” Lectt.IV.-VI., Oxf.,1886.

75

Hexaplorum quÆ supersunt. Ed.Field, Oxon.,1871.

76

Ed. Selwyn, Cantab.,1876; Engl. transl. of C.Celsum and De Principiis, in Ante-Nicene Library, 2vols., Edin.,1869-1872.

77

“Gregory Thaumaturgus, Dionysius of Alex. and Archelaus.” transl. by Prof. Salmond, Edin.,1871.

78

Neander, “Antignosticus, or the Spirit of Tertull.” appended to “Hist. of Planting of Chr. Church.” 2vols., Lond.,1851.

Kaye, “Eccles. Hist. of 2nd and 3rdCents. illustr. from Wr.of Tertull.” 2ed., Camb.,1829.

Tertullian, “Works.” 3vols., Ante-Nicene Lib., Edin.,1869.

79

“Cyprian’s Treatises and Epistles.” Lib. of Fathers, 2vols., Oxf., 1839,1844.

“Writings of Cyprian.” Ante-Nicene Lib., 2vols., Edin.,1868.

Poole, “Life and Times of C.” Oxf.,1840.

PressensÉ, “Martyrs and Apologists.” Lond.,1879, pp.414-438.

80

Dillmann, “Pseudepigraph. des A. Ts.” Herzog, xii. 341.

Reuss, “Hist. of the N. T.” Edin., 1884.

Salmon, “Introd. to N. T.” 2nd ed., Lond., 1886.

81

“Fabricius, Codex pseudepigr. V.T.” Ed.2., Hamb.,1722.

82

Drummond, “Jewish Messiah.” Lond.,1877.

Lawrence, “Book of Enoch.” Oxf.,1821.

Schodde, “Bk. of Enoch.” Andover,1882.

Schurer, “Hist. of Jew. Peo. in Times of J.Chr.” Div.II., Vol.3., pp.59ff., 73ff., 93ff., 134ff.; (Enoch, Assumptio, Ezra, Bk. of Jub.).

Bensly, “Missing Fragment of Lat. Transl. of 4thBk. of Ezra.” Cambr.,1875.

83

Sinker, “Test. XII.Patriarchum.” Cambr.,1869; Appendix,1879.

Malan, “Book of Adam and Eve.” Lond.,1882.

Hort on Bks. of Adam, in Smith’s “Dict. of Chr. Biog.” Lond.,1877.

84

Salmon, “Introd. to N.T.” Lond.,1885; Lect.XII., “Apoc. and Her. Gospels.” pp.226-248.

85

Nicholson, “The Gosp. acc. to the Hebrews.” Lond.,1879.

86

Giles, “Cod. Apoc. N.T.” 2vols., Lond.,1852.

Tischendorf, “Evv. Apocr.” Ed.2, Lps.,1876.

87

Wright, “Apocryphal Acts of the Apostles.” Syriac and English, 2vols., Lond.,1871.

Malan, “The Conflicts of the Holy Apostles.” Lond.,1871.

Tischendorf, “Acta app. Apocr.” Lps.,1851.

88

Phillips, “Addai the Apostle.” Syriac and English, Lond.,1876.

89

Lightfoot, “Comm. on Phil.” 6thed., Lond.,1881; “Diss. on Paul and Seneca.” pp.270-328; “Letters of Paul and Seneca.” pp.329-333.

Lightfoot, “Comm. on Col.” 5ed., Lond.,1880; pp.274-300, “The Epistle from Laodicea.”

90

Dorner, “Hist. of Dev. of Doctr. of Person of Chr.” 5vols., Edin.,1862.

PressensÉ, “Heresy and Christian Doctrine.” Lond.,1879.

91

Deut. xviii. 15; Isa.liii.3; Matt.xii.32; Lukei.35; Johnviii.40; Actsii.22; 1Tim.ii.5.

92

Tertullian says: Ita duo negotia diaboli Praxeas RomÆ procuravit, prophetiam expulit et hÆresim intulit, paracletum fugavit et patrem crucifixit.—Ps.-Tertull.: HÆresim introduxit, quam Victorinus corroborare curavit.

93

Dorner, “Person of Christ.” Vol.ii.

94

PressensÉ, “Life and Practice in the Early Church.” Lond.,1872.

95

Hatch, “The Organization of the Early Christian Churches.” Lond.,1881; “The Growth of Church Institutions.” Lond.,1887.

Bannerman, “Doctr. of the Church.” 2vols., Edin.,1858; espec. vol.i., pp.277-480.

Lightfoot, “Comm. on Phil.” 6thed., Lond.,1881: “Dissertat. on Chr. Ministry.”

Papers in Expositor,1887, on “Origin of Chr. Ministry.” by Sanday, Harnack and others.

96 We are not carried further than this by IrenÆus, iii.3. Similarly, too, Cyprian, De Unitate EcclesiÆ,iv. Tertullian also does not accept the Roman tradition as of supreme authority, but prefers that of Asia Minor in regard to the Easter Controversy, and, in the De Pudicitia, he opposes with bitter invective the penitential discipline of the Roman bishop Zephyrinus or Callistus. So, too, Cyprian repudiates the Roman practice in regard to heretics’ baptism (§35,5); and on the same subject Firmilian of CÆsarea in Cappadocia hesitates not to write: Non pudet Stephanum, Cyprianum pseudo-christum et pseudo-apostolum et dolosum operarium dicere: qui omnia in se esse conscius prÆvenit, ut alteri per mendacium objiceret, quÆ ipse ex merito audire deberet.—Consult:

Blondel, “TraitÉ hist. de la primautÉ.” Gen.,1641.

Salacious, “De Primatu PapÆ.” Lugd. Bat.,1645.

Kenrick, “The Primacy of the Apostolic See Vindicated.” New York,1848.

“The Pope and the Council.” by Janus, Lond.,1869.

97

Wall, “Hist. of Infant Baptism.” with Gale’s Reflections, and Wall’s Defence, 4vols., Oxf.,1836.

Wilberforce, “Doctr. of Holy Baptism.” Lond.,1849.

98 Funk’s assertion that the ?????s?a? and the ????????e?? were not stages in the Catechumenate, but penal ranks in which offending Catechumens were placed, and that there was only one order of Catechumens is untenable for these reasons:
  1. Because the penitential institution presupposes a falling away from the grace of baptism;
  2. Because the Canon of Neo-CÆsarea with its ?at????e??? ?a?t????, ??? ?? ??????????, ?????s??, necessarily implies that ????????e?? is a stage in the Catechumenate;
  3. Because this Canon provides that after the first penal procedure, not after passing through two penitential orders, the sinner will be expelled;
  4. Finally, because the ????????e?? of the Catechumens, just like that of the congregation in prayer, is even in expression something quite different from the ?p?pt?s?? of the penitents.—Consult:

PressensÉ, “Life and Practice in the Early Church.” Lond.,1879, pp.5-36,333.

99

PressensÉ, “Life and Practice in the Early Church.” pp.201-216, 263-286.

Lechler, “Apostolic and Post-Apost. Times.” 2vols., Edin.,1886; Vol.ii.298.

Jacob, “Ecclest. Polity of N.T.” Lond.,1871, pp.187-319.

100

Jacob, “Ecclest. Polit. of N.T.” Lond.,1871, Lect.vii., “The Lord’s Supper.”

Waterland, “Review of the Doctrine of the Eucharist.” Lond.,1737.

101

See, De Doctr. Christiana. II.ii.15.—“Old Latin Biblical Texts.” Edited by John Wordsworth, Bp.of Salisbury, Oxford,1885,etc.

102

Lechler, “Apostolic and Post-Apostolic Times.” Edin.,1886, Vol.ii., pp.301-310.

103

Bosio, “Roma Sotteranea.” Rom.,1632.

De Rossi, “Roma sott. crist.” 3vols., Rome,1864-1877.

Northcote and Brownlow, “Roma Sotteranea.” Lond.,1869.

Withrow, “The Catacombs of Rome.” Lond.,1876.

104

Marriott, “Testimony of the Catacombs.” Lond.,1877.

105

ZÖckler, “The Cross of Christ.” Lond.,1877.

Allen, “Early Christian Symbolism.” Lond.,1887.

Didson, “Chr. Iconography.” 2 vols., Lond.,1886.

106

Schmidt, “The Social Results of Early Christianity.” Lond.,1886.

Brace, “Gesta Christi.” Lond.,1883.

Uhlhorn, “Chr. Charity in the Ancient Church.” Edin.,1883.

PressensÉ, “Life and Practice in Early Church.” Lond.,1879, pp.345-477.

Ryan, “Hist. of the Effects of Relig. upon Mankind.” Dublin,1820.

107

Morinus, “De discipl. in administr. s.poenitentiÆ.” Par.,1651.

Marshall, “Penitential Discipline of the Prim. Church for the First Four Centuries.” Lond.,1844 (1sted.,1718).

Tertullian, “De Poenitentia.” See Transl. in Library of Fathers, Tertullian, vol.i., “Apologetic and Practical Treatises.” Oxf.,1843; XI.Of Repentance, with long and valuable notes by Dr.Pusey, pp.349-408.

108

J. de Soyres, “Montanism and the Primitive Church.” Cambr.,1878.

Cunningham, “The Churches of Asia.” Lond.,1880, p.159 ff.

109

Bunsen, “Hippolytus and his Age.” Lond.,1854.

Wordsworth, “St.Hippolytus and the Church of Rome.” Lond.,1852.

DÖllinger, “Hippolytus and Callistus.” Edin.,1876 (orig. publ.1853).

110

“Library of Fathers.” Oxf.,1843, Cyprian’s Treatises: v.“On Unity of the Church.” vi.“On the Lapsed.” with prefaces.

Also, “Epp. of S. Cyprian.”(1844) xli.-xlv., lii. andlix.

111

“Library of Fathers.” Oxf.,1844; “Epp. of S.Cyprian.” Ep.lii., also Ep.lv.

112

Merivale, “Conversion of the Roman Empire.” Lond.,1864.

Milman, “Hist. of Christianity to Abol. of Pag. in Rom. Emp.” 3vols.,Lond.

Lecky, “Hist. of Eur. Morals.” Vol.ii., “From Constantine to Charlemagne.”

113

DÖllinger, “Fables respecting the Popes of the Middle Ages.” Lond.,1871.

114

Original source is Eusebius, “Life of Constantine.” Trans. Lond.,1842.

See interesting lect. on Constantine in Stanley’s “Hist. of Eastern Church.” Lond.,1861.

Madden, “Christian Emblems on Coins of ConstantineI.” Lond.,1878.

115

Neander, “The Emperor Julian and his Generation.” Lond.,1850.

G.H. Rendall, “The Emperor Julian.” Lond.,1879.

Newman, “Miracles in Eccl. Hist.” Oxf.,1842.

Bp. Wordsworth, “Julian.” in Smith’s Dict. of Biog., vol.iii., pp.484-523.

116

On this whole period consult: Histories of Theodoret, Sozomen, Socrates, and Evagrius (containing much fabulous matter, but useful as contemporary records extending down to A.D.594). Transl. in 4vols., Lond.,1812-1846.

For Theodosius I. see Hefele, “Hist. of Councils.” vol.ii., p.341ff., Edin.,1876.

117

A careful reconstruction of the whole as far as possible has been attempted by Neumann (Leipz.,1880), accompanied by prolegomena and a German translation.

118

Hefele, “Hist. of Church Councils.” Edin.,1872, Vol.i., pp.1-48.

Pusey, “Councils of Ch. from A.D.51 to A.D.381: their constit., obj., and history.” Oxf.,1857.

119

Its original form is probably preserved in a Syriac translation; see Bunsen’s “Analecta AntenicÆna.” ii.45-338, Lond.,1854.

120

First published in the Greek original by Bickell under the title, inapplicable to the first part: ?? d?ata?a? a? d?? ???e?t?? ?a? ?a???e? ?????s?ast???? t?? ????? ?p?st????.

121

Maitland, “The Dark Ages.” Lond.,1844.

Ozanam, “Hist. of Civilization in 5th Cent.” Transl. byGlyn, 2vols.

Montalembert, “Monks of the West, from Benedict to Bernard.” 7vols., Edin.,1861ff.

122

Stephens, “Chrysostom: his Life and Times.” 3rded., London,1883, pp.59ff., 294ff.

123

Hatch, “Organization of the Early Christian Churches.” London,1881, pp.124-139.

Hatch, “Ordination.” in Smith’s “Dict. of Bibl. Antiq.” Vol.ii.

124

Hatch, “Organization of Chr. Ch.” p.161.

Bede, “Eccles. Hist.” iv.1.

125

Dale, “Synod of Elvira, and Christ. Life in the 4thcent.” London,1882.

Lea, “Hist. of Sacerdotal Celibacy.” Philad.,1867.

Lecky, “Hist. of Europ. Morals.” London,1877, Vol.ii., pp.328ff.

Hefele, “Hist. of Christ. Councils.” Edin.,1872, Vol.i., pp.150, 380,435.

126

Neale, “Hist. of the Holy Eastern Church.” 5vols., London,1847-1873.

Stanley, “Lect. on the Eastern Church.” London,1861.

127

Greenwood, “Cathedra Petri: Pol. Hist. of Great Latin Patriarchate from 1st to 16thcent.” 6vols., London,1856ff.

128

Hefele, “Hist. of Councils.” Vol. ii., Edin., 1876, pp. 231 ff., 483 ff.

129

Comp. DÖllinger, “Fables Respecting the Popes of the Middle Ages.” Lond., 1871.

130

Milman, “Latin Christianity.” Vol.i.

131

Bright, “Hist. of Church from A.D.313-451.” 2ed., Cambr.,1869.

Milman, “Latin Christianity.” Vol.i.

132

Kellett, “Pope Gregory the Great and his Relations with Gaul.” (Cambridge Essays, No.ii.), Cambridge,1889.

133

Engl. Transl.:

“Eccles. Hist. with Life of Euseb. by Valesius.” Lond.,1843.

“Theophania, or Div. Manifest. of the Lord.” from Syr. by Dr.Sam.Lee, Lond.,1843.

“Life of Constantine.” Lond.,1844.

“Life of Eusebius.” by Bright, prefixed to Oxf. ed. of Eccl. Hist. of1872.

134

“Festal Epp. of Athanasius.” (transl. from Syriac discovered in1842 by Tattam, and first edited by Cureton in1848), Oxf.,1854.

135

“Treatises against Arians.” 2vols., Oxf.,1842 (newed., 1vol.,1877).

“Historical Tracts.” Oxf.,1843; “Select Tracts,” with Newman’s Notes, 2vols., Lond.,1881.

136

Newman’s, “Hist. Sketches.” Vol.ii., chap.v; Sketches of Basil, Gregory, etc. Originally publ. under title “Church of the Fathers.” Lond.,1842.

137

Ullmann, “Gregory Nazianzen.” Oxford,1855; and Newman “Church of the Fathers.”

138

Cyril’s Comm. on Luke is transl. from the Syriac by Dr.Payne Smith, Oxf.,1859.

139

A very full and admirable account of Synesius and his writings is given by Rev. T.R. Halcomb in Smith’s “Dict. of Chr. Biog.” Vol.iii., pp.756-780.

140

Neander, “Life of Chrysostom.” Lond.,1845.

Stephens, “Life of Chrysostom.” 3rded., Lond.,1883.

Chase, “Chrysostom: a Study.” Cambr.,1887.

His Homilies and Addresses are transl. in 15vols. in the “Lib. of the Fathers.” Oxf.,1839-1851.

Various Eng. translations of the tract “On the Priesthood.”

141

Newman’s “Historical Sketches.” Vol.ii., chap.i., “Theodoret.”

142

Translated by Dean Church in “Lib. of the Fathers.” Oxf.,1838; with interesting and instructive Preface by Newman.

143

Ueberweg, “Hist. of Philosophy.” Lond.,1872, Vol.i., pp.349-352.

Colet, “On the Hierarchies of Dionysius.” ed.by Lupton, Lond.,1869.

Wescott, “Dionysius the Areopagite.” in Contemp. Review for May,1867.

144

Etheridge, “The Syrian Churches: their Early Hist., Liturg. and Lit.” Lond.,1846.

145

Morris, “Select Writings of Ephraim the Syrian.” Oxford, 1817.

Burgess, “Repentance of Nineveh, Metrical Homily by Ephraem.” Lond., 1853.

“Select Metrical Hymns and Homilies of Eph. Syr.” Lond., 1853.

146

Newman, “Church of the Fathers.” 2nded., London,1842. Reprinted in Hist. Sketches, vol.ii.

Gilly, “Vigilantius and his Times.” London,1844.

147

“Lib. of Fathers.” in vol. of Cyprian’s Epps., Oxf.,1844, pp.318-384. For phrase quoted, see p.322.

148

A good account of the writings of Jerome is given by the late Prof.William Ramsay in Smith’s “Dict. of Grk. and Rom. Biogr.” Vol.ii., p.460.

Milman, “Hist. of Chr.” Vol.iii., ch.xi.

Cutts, “St.Jerome.” Lond.,1877.

Gilly, “Vigilantius and his Times.” Lond.,1844.

149

Gilly, “Vigilantius and his Times.” London,1844.

150

Newman’s “Arians of the 4thCentury.” London,1838.

Gwatkin, “Studies of Arianism.” Camb.,1882.

Hefele, “Hist. of Councils.” Vols.i.ii., Edin., 1872,1876.

Newman’s “Tracts Theolog. and Eccles.” Chap.ii.; Doctrinal Causes of Arianism.

“Select Treatises of Athanasius.” Ed. by Newman, 2vols., London,1881, Vol.2 containing notes on Arius, Athanasius,etc.

151

Hefele, “Hist. of Councils.” I., pp.231-447.

Kaye, “Hist. of Council of NicÆa.” London,1853.

Tillemont, “Hist. of Arians and Council of Nice.” London,1721.

152

Newman’s “Select Treat. of Athanasius.” Vol.ii., p.196f.

Hefele, “Hist. of Councils.” Vol.ii., Edin.,1876, p.193.

153

Newman’s “Select Treat. of Athanasius.” Vol.ii., p.282ff.

Hefele, “Hist. of Councils.” ii., p.217.

154

Hefele, “Hist. of Councils.” ii., pp.340-373.

Hort, “Two Dissertations.” ii., On the Constantinople Creed and other Eastern Creeds of the 4thcent., Camb.,1874.

155

Swete, “The Hist. of the Doctr. of the Procession of the Holy Spirit from Apost. Age to Death of Charlemagne.” Cambr.,1876.

Pusey, “On the clause ‘And the Son.’” Oxf.,1876.

156

Hefele, “Hist. of Councils.” ii., p.348ff., §97, The Tome and the Creed.

157

Stephens, “Chrysostom.” pp.287-305.

Hefele, “Hist. of Councils.” ii., p.430ff.

158

The most useful and complete account of Chrysostom is that of Stephens. Consult also Milman, “Hist. of Chr.” Vol.iii., pp.206ff.

159

Dorner, “Hist. of the Development of the Doctr. of the Person of Christ.” 5vols., Edin.,1861.

160

Newman, “Tracts Theological and Ecclesiastical.” Chap.iii., Apollinarianism.

161

Hefele, “Hist. of Councils.” Vol.iii., pp.1-156.

162

Most informing about all these transactions is Hefele, “Hist. of Councils.” iii., Edin.,1883; (Robber Synod, p.241ff.; Chalcedon, p.451ff.).

Perry, “Second Council of Ephesus.” London,1877.

Bright, “Hist. of Church from A.D.313-451.” Cambr.,1869.

163

Butler, “Ancient Coptic Churches.” 2vols., London,1884.

164

DÖllinger, “Fables respecting the Popes of the Middle Ages.” Lond.,1871.

Willis, “Pope Honorius and the New Roman Dogma.” Lond.,1879.

Bottalla, “Pope Honorius before the Tribunal of Reason and History.” London,1868.

165

Wiggers, “Augustinianism and Pelagianism.” Andover,1840.

MÜller, “Chr. Doctrine of Sin.” 2vols., Edin.,1868.

Ritschl, “Hist. of Chr. Doctr. of Justific. and Reconciliation.” Edin.,1872.

166

Laidlaw, “The Bible Doctrine of Man.” Edin.,1879.

Heard, “Tripartite Nat. of Man.” 3rded., Edin.,1870, pp.189-200.

Delitzsch, “Biblical Psychology.” 2nded., Edin.,1869, pp.128-142.

Beck, “Outlines of Biblical Psychology.” Edin.,1877, p.10.

167

For an entirely different representation of the Augustinian system see Cunningham, “S. Austin and his Place in Hist. of Chr. Thought.” Lond.,1886; esp. chaps.ii. andiii., pp.45-107.

A good outline and defence in Hodge’s “System. Theol.” Edin.,1874, Vol.ii., pp.333-353.

Mosheim, “Eccl. Hist.” ed. by Dr.J.S. Reid, Lond.,1880, p.210, notes3 and4; (pt.II., chap.v., §25.)

Mozley, “Augustinian Doctrine of Predestination.” Lond.,1855.

168

Hodge, “Systematic Theology.” Vol.ii., pp.166-168.

169

Lardner, “Credibility of the Gospel Hist.” Vol.iv., London,1743.

170

Butcher, “The Ecclesiastical Calendar.” London.

Hampson, “Medii Ævi Kalend.”

171

Gieseler, “Ecclesiastical History.” Edinburgh,1848, Vol.ii., pp.141-145.

172

Tyler, “Image Worship of Ch. of Rome contrary to Scripture and the Prim. Ch.” London,1847.

173

Tyler, “Worship of Virgin Mary contrary to Script. and Faith of Ch. of first 5Cents.” London,1851.

Clagett, “Prerogatives of Anna the Mother of God.” London,1688. Also by same: “Discourse on Worship of Virgin and Saints.” London,1686.

174

Cosin, “Scholastic History of Popish Transubstantiation.” Lond.,1676.

175

Reuss, “History of the N.T. Scriptures.” Edin.,1884, §377.

Keil, “Introduction to the O.T.” Edin.,1870, Vol.ii., pp.201-203.

176

Swainson, “The Nicene and Apostles’ Creeds.” Camb.,1875.

Westcott, “The Historic Faith.” Lond.,1883, noteiii., theCreeds.

Harvey, “Hist. and Theology of the three Creeds.” Camb.,1854.

Hort, Two Dissertations:II. “The Constantinopolitan Creed and the Eastern Creeds of 4thcent.” Camb.,1876.

Schaff, “Creeds of Christendom.” Edin.,1877, vol.i.

Lumby, “History of the Creeds.” Camb.,1873.

Waterland, “Crit. Hist. of Athanasian Creed.” Camb.,1724.

Heurtley, “The Athanasian Creed.” Oxf.,1872.

Ommaney, “Ath. Creed: an Exam. of Recent Theories respecting its Date and Origin.” Lond.,1875.

177

Neale, “Hymns of the Eastern Church.” Lond.,1863.

“MediÆval Hymns and Sequences.” Lond.,1863.

Gieseler, “Ecclesiastical History.” Vol.iii., p.353.

178

Hawkins, “History of Music.” Lond.,1853.

179

Hammond, “Ancient Liturgies.” Oxf.,1878.

Neale and Littledale, “Translations of Primitive Liturgies.” Lond.,1869.

Neale, “Essays on Liturgiology.” Lond.,1867.

180

Marriott, “Vestiarium Christianum: Origin and gradual development of Dress of Holy Ministry of Church.” Lond.,1868.

181

Woltmann and Woermann, “History of Painting.” 2vols., Lond.,1886; vol.i., “Anc., Early Chr. and MediÆval Painting.” ed.by Prof. Sidney Colvin.

“Handbook of Painting: Italian Schools. Based on KÜgler’s Handbook.” by Eastlake; new ed. by Layard, 2vols., Lond.,1886.

182

Ozanam, “Hist. of Civilization during the 5th Century.” 2vols.

Lecky, “Hist. of European Morals.” Vol.ii.

183

Smith’s “Dictionary of Christian Biography.” vol.iii., p.367.

184

Gilly, “Vigilantius and his Times.” Lond.,1840.

185

Gieseler, “Eccl. Hist.” ii.148.

186

Ludolphus, “History of Ethiopia.” London,1684.

187

Malan, “Gregory the Illuminator: his Life and Times.” London,1868.

Article by Lipsius on Eznik in Smith’s “Dictionary of Chr. Biography.” Vol.ii., p.439.

188

Muir, “Life of Mohammed and Hist. of Islam.” 4vols., Lond.

Bosworth Smith, “Mohammed and Mohammedanism.” Lond.,1874.

MÜhleisen-Arnold, “Islam, its Hist., Chr. and Rel. to Christianity.” 3rded., Lond.,1874.

Deutsch, “Literary Remains: Islam.” Lond.,1874.

Stephens, “Christianity and Islam.” Lond.,1877.

Mills, “Hist. of Mohammedanism.” Lond.,1817.

189

Muir, “Annals of the Earlier Khalifate.”

190

Finlay, “Hist. of Greece from Rom. Conquest.” 7vols., Lond., 1864, newed.,1877; vols.ii. andiii.

Bower’s “Lives of Popes.” Vols.iii. andiv., Lond.,1754.

Comber, “Disc. on 2nd Council of NicÆa.” Reprinted in Gibson’s “Preserv. from Popery.” Lond.,1848.

Didron, “Christian Iconography.” 2vols., Lond.,1886.

191

Mendham, “The Seventh General Council, the Second of NicÆa.” in which the worship of images was established.

192

Allatius, “De eccl. occid. et orient. perpetua consensione.” Colon.,1669.

Swete, “Hist. of the Procession of the Holy Spirit.” Camb.,1876.

Ffoulkes, “Christendom’s Divisions.” London.

Neale, “Holy Eastern Church.” 5vols., London,1847.

193

Popoff, “Hist. of Council of Florence.” Transl. from Russian by Neale, London,1861.

194

Lupton, “St. John of Damascus.” London,1882.

195

Badger, “The Nestorians and their Rituals.” 2vols., London,1852.

196

Baring-Gould, “Curious Myths of the Middle Ages.” Lond.,1881.

197

Murawieff, “Hist. of the Church of Russia.” Trans. from the Russ., Lond.,1842.

Romanoff, “Sketches of the Rites and Customs of the GrÆco-Russian Church.” Lond.,1869.

198

Potthast, “Biblioth. Hist. Modii Ævi.” Berol.,1862, with suppl. in1868.

D’Achery, “Vett. Script. Spicilegium.” (1655), 3vols., Par.,1783.

Eccard, “Corpus Hist. Medii Ævi.” 2vols., Lps.,1723.

Du Chesne, “Hist. Francorum Serr.” 5vols., Par.,1636.

Parker, “Rer. Brit. Serr. Vetust.” Lugd. B.,1587.

Gale, “Hist. Brit., Saxon., Anglo-Dan. Scrr.” 2vols., Oxf.,1691.

Wharton, “Anglia Sacra.” 2vols., Lond.,1691.

Wilkins, “Conc. Brit. et Hib.” 4vols., Lond.,1737.

Haddan and Stubbs, “Councils and Eccles. Documents.” (Revision of Wilkins), Lond.,1879ff.

Maitland, “The Dark Ages: Essays on the State of Relig. and Lit. in 9th, 10th, 11th, and 12thCenturies.” Lond.,1844.

199

Bryce, “The Holy Roman Empire.” Lond.,1866.

Ranke, “History of the Latin and Teutonic Nations.” Lond.,1886.

200

Ebrard, “Christian Apologetics.” 3vols., Edin., 1886-1887, Vol.ii., p.407; “The Religion of the Germans and that of the Slavs.”

201

Mallet, “Northern Antiquities.” London,1848.

Hallam, “Europe during the Middle Ages.”

Guizot, “Hist. of Civiliz. in Europe.”

202

Hodgkin, “Italy and her Invaders: A.D.376-476.” 2vols., London,1880.

203

Scott, “Ulfilas, the Apostle of the Goths.” Cambr.,1885.

Douse, “Introduction to the Gothic of Ulfilas.” London,1886.

Bosworth’s “Gothic and Anglo-Saxon Gospels.” Oxf.,1874.

204

Gibbon, “Decline and Fall of Roman Empire.” Chaps.xxxiii., xxxvi.,xxxvii.

205

Freeman, “Historical Essays.” 3rdseries, Lond.; “The Goths at Ravenna.”

206

Ussher, “Brit. Eccl. Antiqu.” Lond.,1639.

Perry, “Hist. of English Church.” i., Lond.,1882.

Lanigan, “Eccl. Hist. of Ireland.” 4vols., 2nded., Dublin,1829.

Stokes, “Ireland and the Celtic Ch.” Lond.,1886.

Lingard, “Hist. and Antiqu. of Anglo-Sax. Ch.” 2vols., Lond.,1845.

Maclauchlan, “Early Scottish Church.” Edinb.,1865.

Reeves, “The Culdees of the British Islands.” Dublin,1864.

Skene, “Celtic Scotland.” 3vols., Edin.,1876; 2ed.,1886.

Bright, “Chapters of Early Eng. Ch. Hist.” Oxf.,1878.

Pryce, “Ancient British Church.” Lond.,1886.

207

Todd, “Life of St.Patrick.” Dublin,1864.

Cusack, “Life of St.Patrick.” Lond.,1871.

O’Curry, “Lects. on Anc. Irish History.” Dublin,1861.

Writings of St.Patrick. Transl. and ed. by Stokes and Wright, Lond.,1887.

208

Maclauchlan, “Early Scottish Church.” Pp.145-205.

Adamnan, “Life of Columba.” Ed. by Dr.Reeves, Dublin,1857.

Smith, “Life of Columba.” Edin.,1798.

Forbes, “Lives of Ninian, Columba, Kentigern.” in series of Historians of Scotland.

209

Ussher, “Discourse of the Religion anciently Professed by the Irish and British.” Lond.,1631.

Maclauchlan, “Early Scottish Church.” Pp.239-250.

Warren, “Ritual and Liturgy of the Celtic Church.” Oxf.,1881.

210

Soames, “The Anglo-Saxon Church.” 4thed., Lond.,1856.

Stanley, “Historical Memorials of Canterbury.” Lond.,1855.

Hook, “Lives of Archbishops of Canterbury.” Vol.i.

Sharon Turner, “Hist. of Anglo-Saxons to the Roman Conquest.” 6ed., 3vols., Lond.,1836.

211

Lappenburg, “Anglo-Saxon Kings.” Lond.,1845.

Bede, “Eccles. History.” BookIII.

Maclauchlan, “Early Scottish Church.” Pp.217-238.

212

Gildas († A.D.570), “De excidio BritanniÆ.” Engl. transl. by Giles, London, 1841.

Bede († A.D.735), “Eccles. Hist. of Engl.” Transl. by Giles, London, 1840.

213

Lanigan, “Eccl. Hist. of Ireland.” iii., ch. 13.

Innes, “Ancient Inhab. of Scotland.” in the Series of Historians of Scotland.

214

Maclauchlan, “Early Scottish Church.” p.435.

Reeves, “The Culdees of the British Islands.” Dublin,1864.

Robertson, “Scotland under her Early Kings.” Edin., 2vols., 1862.

Merivale, “Conversion of the Northern Nations.” London,1866.

Maclear, “Apostles of MediÆval Europe.”

216 That he first received the Latin name after his consecration as bishop in A.D.723 is rendered more than doubtful by the fact that it is found in letters of earlier date. It is probably only a Latinizing of the Anglo-Saxon Winfrid or Wynfrith (from Vyn=fortune, luck, health; frid or frith=peace; therefore: peaceful, wholesome fortune) into the name, widely spread in Christian antiquity, of Bonifatius (from bonumfatum, Greek: Eutyches, good luck). But the transposition into the form Bonifacius which might seem the equivalent of the Anglo-Saxon word “Benefactor” of the German people, is first met with, although even then only occasionally, in the 8thcentury, but afterwards always more and more frequently, and then is given to the popes and other earlier bearers of the name. By the 15thcentury the original and etymological style of writing the name and that used in early documents had been completely discarded and forgotten, till modern philology, diplomatics and epigraphies have again clearly vindicated the earlier form.
217

Wright, “Biog. Britannica Literaria.” Lond.,1842.

Cox, “Life of Boniface.” Lond.,1853.

Hope, “Boniface.” London,1872.

Maclear, “Apostles of MediÆval Europe.”

218

Trench, “Lectures on MediÆval Church History.” Lond.,1877.

Hardwick, “History of Christian Church during Middle Ages.”

219

Mosheim, “Eccl. Hist.” Ed. by Reid, London,1880, p.285, Cent.viii., pt.ii., ch.5.

Wright, “Biographia Brit. Literaria.” London,1842.

220

Milman, “Hist. of Latin Christianity.” Vol.ii., Trench’s “Lectures on MediÆval Church History.”

221

“William of Malmesbury’s Chronicle of Kings of England.” Bk.I., ch.4.

222

Freeman, “Historical Essays.” 2ndseries: “The Southern Slavs.”

223

Adam of Bremen, “Gesta Hammaburgensia.” A.D.788-1072.

Pontoppidan, “Annales Eccles. DanicÆ.” Copenhag.,1741.

Merivale, “Conversion of the Northern Nations.” London,1865.

224

Geijer, “History of the Swedes.” Transl. by Turner, Lond.,1847.

225

Muir, “Annals of Early Khalifate.”

Ockley, “Hist. of Saracens and their Conquests in Syria, Persia and Egypt.”

226

CondÉ, “History of Dominion of Arabs in Spain.” 3vols.

Freeman, “Hist. and Conquests of the Saracens.” 2nded., Lond.,1876.

Abd-el-Hakem, “History of the Conquest of Spain.” Tr.from Arabic by Jones, GÖtt.,1858.

227

Kingsley, “Roman and Teuton.” Lectures in Univ. of Cambr.: “The Popes and the Lombards.”

228

Crakenthorp, “The Defence of Constantine, with a Treatise on the Pope’s Temporal Monarchy.” Lond.,1621.

229

Platina, “Lives of Popes.” Under JohnVII.

Bower, “Lives of Popes.” Vol.iv.

Blondel, “Joanna Papissa.” Amst.,1657.

Hase, “Church History.” New York,1855, p.186.

230

Cunningham, “Discussions on Church Principles.” Edin.,1863, pp.101-163; “Temporal Supremacy of the Pope and Gallican Liberties.”

Barrow, “Pope’s Supremacy.” London,1683.

231

Hatch, “Growth of Church Institutions.” ch.viii., National Churches, pp.139-154.

232

Hefele, “History of Councils.” iii.69, 131,149.

Field, “Of the Church.” Reprint by Eccl. Hist. Society, 5vols., London,1847; vol.iii., pp.7,245ff.

Hatch, “Growth of Church Institutions.” ch.vii., The Metropolitan, pp.128-135.

233

Lea, “Studies in Church History.” Philad.,1869.

Lecky, “History of European Morals.” 3rded., 2vols., London,1877.

234

Hatch, “Growth of Church Institutions.” London,1887, p.43.

235

Marriott, “Vestiarium Christianum.” P.187ff., London,1868.

236

Hatch, “Growth of Church Institutions.” Ch.v., The Parish, pp.89-97.

237

Hatch, “Growth of Church Institutions.” Ch.ix., The Canonical Rule, pp.157-172; Ch.x., The Cathedral Chapter, pp.175-190.

238

Hatch, “Growth of Ch. Instit.” Ch.xi., The Chapter of the Diocese, pp.193-208.

Stubbs, “Constit. Hist. of England.” Vol.iii.

239

Walcott, “Cathedralia.”

Ibid., “Sacred ArchÆology.”

Hatch, “Growth of Church Institutions.” Ch.iii., Fixed Tenure of Parish Priest; Ch.iv., The Benefice.

240

Lecky, “Hist. of Europ. Morals.” ii.,183-248.

Montalembert, “Monks of West from Benedict to Bernard.” 7vols., Edin.,1861ff.

241

Hatch, “Growth of Church Institutions.” Ch.vi., Tithes and their Distribution, pp.101-117.

242 Roth, however, regards this divisio as putting a complete stop to the secularization of church property.
243

Hatch, “Growth of Ch. Institutions.” Ch.iv., The Benefice, pp.61-77.

Art. “Benefice.” in Smith’s “Dict. of Chr. Antiquities.”

244

Ayliffe, “Parergon Juris Canonici.” Lond.,1726.

Guizot, “Hist. of Civilization.” Transl. by Hazlitt, Lond.,1846.

Walcott, “Sacred ArchÆology.”

245

Blondel, “Pseudo-Isid. et Turrianus vapulantes.” Genev.,1628.

246

Hopkins, “The Organ, its hist. and construct.” Lond.,1855.

247

Guest, “History of English Rhythms.” Vol.ii., London,1838.

Wright, “Biogr. Brit. Lit. Anglo-Saxon Period.” London,1842.

Thorpe, “CÆdmon’s Paraphrase in Anglo-Saxon with Engl. Transl.” London,1832.

Conybeare, “Illustr. of Anglo-Saxon Poetry.” London,1827.

248

Evans, “Treatise on Chr. Doct. of Marriage.” New York,1870.

Hammond, “On Divorces.” In his Works, vol.i., London,1674.

Cosin, “Argument on the Dissolution of Marriage.” Works, vol.iv., Oxf.,1854.

Tertullian, Treatise in “Lib. of Fath.” Oxf.,1854, with two Essays by Pusey, “On Second Marriages of the Clergy.” and “On Early Views as to Marriage after Divorce.”

249

Babington, “Influence of Chr. in promoting the Abolition of Slavery in Europe.” London,1864.

Edwards, “Inquiry into the State of Slavery in the Early and Middle Ages of the Christian Era.” Edin.,1836.

250

Smith’s “Dict. of Chr. Antiq.” Vol.i., pp.785-792; Arts.: “Hospitality, Hospitals, Hospitium.”

251

Haddan and Stubbs, “Councils and Eccl. Documents.” Vol.iii., Oxf.,1871.

252

Barington, “Lit. Hist. of the Middle Ages.” Lond.,1846.

Hallam, “Europe in Middle Ages.” 2vols., Lond.,1818.

Trench, “Lect. on Med. Ch. Hist.” Lond.,1877.

253

Lorentz, “Life of Alcuin.” Transl. by Slee, Lond.,1837.

254

Kingsley, “Roman and Teuton: Paulus Diaconus.”

255

Hampden, “The Scholastic Philosophy in its rel. to Chr. Theology.” Oxf.,1833.

Ueberweg, “Hist. of Philosophy.” Vol.i., pp.358-365.

256

Mullinger, “Schools of Charles the Great and Restoration of Education in the 9thcent.” Cambr.,1877.

257

Cassiodorus’ work in 12bks., De rebus gestes Gotorum, has indeed been lost, but about A.D.550 Jornandes, who also used other documents, embodied this work in his De Getarum orig. et reb. gestis.

258

Gildas wrote about A.D.560 his: Liber querulis de excidio BritanniÆ (Eng. transl. in “Six Old English Chronicles.” London, Bohn).

259

Nennius wrote about A.D.850 his: Eulogium BritanniÆ s.Hist. Britonum (Engl. transl. in “Six Old Engl. Chron.”).

260

Collected Ed. of Alfred’s works, by Bosworth, 2vols., Lond.,1858.

Fox, “Whole Wks. of Alfred the Great, with Essays on Hist., Arts and Manners of 9thcent.” 3vols., Oxf.,1852.

Spelman, “Life of Alfred the Great.” Oxf.,1709.

Pauli, “Life of Alfred the Gt.” transl. with Alfred’s Orosius, Lond.,1853.

Hughes, “Alfred the Great.”

Giles, “Life and Times of King Alfred the Great.” Lond.,1848.

261

Robertson, “Hist. of Chr. Church.” Vol. ii., London,1856; pp.154ff.

Dorner, “Hist. Development of Person of Chr.” Div.II., vol.i.

262

Ussher, “Gotteschalci et controv. ab eo motÆ hist.” Dubl.,1631.

263

Principal authorities for last two sections:

Adam of Bremen, “Gesta Hamburg eccl. Pontificum.” and

Saxo Grammaticus, “Hist. Danica.”

264

Snorro Sturleson’s, “Heimskringla, or Chronicle of the Kings of Norway.” Transl. from the Icelandic by Laing, 3vols., London,1844.

265

Cosmas of Prague [†A.D.1125], “Chronicon Prag.”

266

“The Book of Ser Marco Polo the Venetian.” Edited with Commentary by Col.Yule, 2vols., London,1871.

267

Michaud, “History of the Crusades.” Transl. by Robson, 3vols., London,1852.

Mill, “History of the Crusades.” 2vols., London,1820.

“Chronicles of the Crusades: Contemporary Narratives of Richard Coeur de Lion, by Richard of Devizes and Geoffrey de Vinsauf, and of the Crusade of St.Louis, by Lord John de Joinville.” London (Bohn).

Gibbon, “History of Crusades.” London,1869.

268 Pulleni dicuntur, vel quia recentes et novi, quasi pulli respectu Surianorum reputati sunt, vel quia principaliter de gente ApuliÆ matres habuerunt. Cum enim paucas mulieres adduxissent nostri, qui in terras remanserunt, de regno ApuliÆ, eo quod propius esset aliis regionibus, vocantes mulieres, cum eis matrimonia contraxerunt.
269

Stubbs, “Chronicle and Memorials of RichardI.” London,1864.

270

Prescott, “History of Ferdinand and Isabella.” Good edition by Kirk, in 1vol., London,1886.

Geddes, “History of Expulsion of Moriscoes.” In “Miscell. Tracts.” Vol.i., London,1714.

McCrie, “Hist. of Prop. and Suppr. of Reformation in Spain.” London,1829.

Ranke, “History of Reformation.” Transl. by Mrs. Austin, vol.iii., London,1847.

271

Milman, “History of the Jews.” Book xxiv.1, “The Feudal System.”

272

“De sua conversione.” In Carpzov’s edit. of the “Pugio Fidei” of Raimund Martini, §103,9.

273

Milman, “History of the Jews.” 3vols., London,1863; bks.xxiv.,xxvi.

Prescott, “Ferdinand and Isabella.” Pt.I., ch.xvii.

274

Bryce, “The Holy Roman Empire.” London,1866.

O’Donoghue, “History of Church and Court of Rome, from Constantine to Present Time.” 2vols., London,1846.

Bower’s “History of the Popes.” Vol.v.

275

For Lanfranc, see Hook, “Lives of Archbishops of Canterbury.” Vol.ii., London,1861.

276

Bowden, “Life and Pontificate of GregoryVII.” 2vols., London,1840.

Villemain, “Life of GregoryVII.” Transl. by Brockley, 2vols., London,1874.

Stephen, “Essays in Ecclesiastical Biography.” 2vols., London,1850.

Hallam, “Middle Ages.” Vol.i., London,1840.

Milman, “Latin Christianity.” Vol.iii., London,1854.

277

Church, “St.Anselm.” London,1870.

Rule, “Life and Times of St.Anselm.” 2vols., London,1883.

Hook, “Lives of Archb. of Canterbury.” Vol.ii., London,1879, pp.169-276.

278

“Vita et EpistolÆ ThomÆ Cantuari.” Edited by Giles, 4vols., London,1846.

Morris, “Life and Martyrdom of Thomas ÀBecket.” London,1859.

Robertson, “Thomas ÀBecket, Archbishop of Canterbury.” London,1859.

“Materials for Life of Thomas ÀBecket.” 2vols., London,1875.

Hook, “Lives of Archbishops of Canterbury.” Vol.ii., London,1879, pp.354-507.

Stanley, “Memorials of Canterbury.” London,1855.

Freeman, “Historical Essays.” First Series, EssayIV.

279

On Stephen Langton see

Pearson, “History of England during Early and Middle Ages.” Vol.ii.

Milman, “History of Latin Christianity.” Vol.iv., London,1854.

Hook, “Lives of Archbishops of Canterbury.” Vol.ii., 4thedition, London,1879, pp.657-761.

Maurice, “Lives of English Popular Leaders. 1.Stephen Langton.” London.

280

Kingston, “History of FrederickII., King of the Romans.” London,1862.

281

Stubbs, “Memorials of St.Dunstan. Collection of six Biographies.” London,1875.

Soames, “Anglo-Saxon Church.” London,1835.

Hook, “Lives of Archb. of Canterbury.” Vol.i., pp.382-426, London,1860.

282

Luard, “Roberti Grosseteste, Episcopi quondam Lincolniensis EpistolÆ.” London,1862.

283 According to Giordano of Giano, who himself was there, the number of brothers present was about 3,000, and the people of the neighbourhood supplied them so abundantly with food and drink that they had at last to put a stop to their bringing. But soon the tradition of the order multiplied the 3,000 into 5,000, and transformed the quite natural account of their support into a “miraculum stupendum,” parallel to the feeding of the 5,000 in the wilderness (Matt.xiv.15-21).
284

Trench, “The Mendicant Orders.” in “Lectures on MediÆval Church History.” London,1878.

285

Milman, “History of Latin Christianity.” Vol.v.

Wadding, “Annales Minorum Fratrum.” 8vols., Lugd.,1625.

Stephen, “St.Francis of Assisi.” In “Essays in Ecclesiastical Biography.” London,1860.

286

“Annales Ordinis PrÆdicatorum.” Vol.i., Rome,1746.

287

Gieseler, “Ecclesiastical History.” §72, Edin.,1853, vol.iii., pp.268-276.

288

Addison, “History of the Knights Templars.” etc., London,1842.

289

Taafe, “Order of St.John of Jerusalem.” 4vols., London,1852.

290

Ueberweg, “History of Philosophy.” Vol.i., pp.355-377.

Hampden, “The Scholastic Philosophy considered in its relation to Christian Theology.” Oxford,1832.

Maurice, “MediÆval Philosophy.” London,1870.

Harper, “The Metaphysics of the School.” London,1880f.

291

Kirkpatrick, “The Historically Received Conception of a University.” London,1857.

Hagenbach, “EncyclopÆdia of Theology.” Transl. by Crooks and Hurst, New York,1884, §18, pp.50,51.

292

Cunningham, “Historical Theology.” Edinburgh,1870, vol.i., ch.xv., “The Canon Law.” Pp.426-438.

293

RÄbiger, “Theological EncyclopÆdia.” Vol.i., p.28, Edin.,1884.

294

Maitland, “The Dark Ages: a Series of Essays, to Illustrate the State of Religion and Literature in the Ninth, Tenth, Eleventh, and Twelfth Centuries.” London,1844.

295

The Aelfric Society founded in1842 has edited his Anglo-Saxon writings and those of others. The Homilies were edited by Thorpe in 2vols., in1843 and1846. “Select Monuments of Doctrine and Worship of Catholic Church in England before the Norman Conquest, consisting of Aelfric’s Paschal Homily.” Etc., London,1875.

On Aelfric and Ethelwold see an admirable sketch, with full references to and appropriate quotations from early chronicles, in Hook’s “Lives of the Archbishops of Canterbury.” Vol.i., pp.434-455.

296

Macpherson on “Anselm’s Theory of the Atonement; its Place in History.” In Brit. and For. Evang. Review for1878, pp.207-232.

297

Church, “St.Anselm.” London,1870.

Rule, “Life and Times of St.Anselm.” 2vols., London,1883.

298

On Anselm’s and AbÆlard’s theories of atonement, see Ritschl, “History of Christian Doctrine of Justification and Reconciliation.” Pp.22-40., Edin.,1872.

299

Berington, “History of the Lives of AbÆlard and Heloise.” London,1787.

Ueberweg, “History of Philosophy.” Vol.i., pp.386-397, London,1872.

300

Neander, “St.Bernard and his Times.” London,1843.

Morison, “Life and Times of St.Bernard.” London,1863.

301

RÄbiger “Theological EncyclopÆdia.” Vol.i., p.27, Edin.,1884.

302

Westcott, “Epistles of St.John.” London,1883.

Dissertation on “The Gospel of Creation.” Pp.277-280.

Bruce, “Humiliation of Christ.” Edin.,1876, pp.354ff., 487f.

303

This work is entitled Contra quatuor labyrinthos FranciÆ, Seu contra novas hÆreses, quas AbÆlardus, Lombardus, Petrus Pictaviensis, et Gilbertus Porretanus libris sententiarum acuunt limant, roborant Ll.IV.

304

Ueberweg, “History of Philosophy.” London,1872, Vol.i., pp.405-428.

Ginsburg, “The Kabbalah, its doctrines, development, and literature.” London,1865.

Palmer, “Oriental Mysticism.” A treatise on the Suffistic and Unitarian Theosophy of the Persians, compiled from native sources, London,1867.

305

Sighart, “Albert the Great: his Life and Scholastic Labours.” Translated from the French by T.A. Dixon, London,1876.

306

Hampden, “Life of Thomas Aquinas: a Dissertation of the Scholastic Philosophy of the Middle Ages.” London,1848.

Cicognani, “Life of Thomas Aquinas.” London,1882.

Townsend, “Great Schoolmen of the Middle Ages.” London,1882.

Vaughan, “Life and Labours of St.Thomas of Aquino.” 2vols., London,1870.

307

“Monumenta Franciscana.” in “Chronicles and Memorials of Great Britain and Ireland.” Edited for the “Master of the Rolls Series.” By Brewer, London,1858.

In addition to the Opus Majus referred to above, Brewer has edited Fr.Rogeri Bacon Opera quÆdum inedita, vol.i., containing Opus Tertium, Opus Minus, and Compendium PhilosophiÆ.

308

Neubauer, “Jewish Controversy and the ‘Pugio Fidei.’” In Expositor for February and March,1888.

309

Hodge, “Systematic Theology.” Vol.iii., pp.492-497.

310

Preuss, “The Romish Doctrine of the Immaculate Conception traced from its Source.” Edinburgh,1867.

311

Maccall, “Christian Legends of Middle Ages, from German of von Bulow.” London.

Cox and Jones, “Popular Romances of the Middle Ages.” London.

Baring Gould, “Curious Myths of the Middle Ages.” London,1884.

“The Legend of St.Ursula and the Virgin Martyrs of Cologne.” London,1860.

312

“Liturgical Poetry of Adam of St.Victor.” With transl. into English, and notes, by Wrangham, 3vols., London,1881.

Bird, “The Latin Hymns of the Church.” In the Sunday Magazine for1865, pp.530ff., 679ff., 776ff.

Trench, “Sacred Latin Poetry.” London,1849.

Neale, “MediÆval Hymns.”

313

“Christus ist erstanden von der Marter Banden.”

314

Eastlake, “History of the Gothic Revival.” London,1872. Norton, “Historical Studies of Church Building in the Middle Ages.” New York,1880.

Didron, “History of Christian Art in the Middle Ages.” London,1851.

315

KÜgler, “Handbook of Painting: Italian Schools.” Translated by Eastlake, London,1855.

Warrington, “History of Stained Glass.” London,1850.

316

Kingsley, “The Saint’s Tragedy.” London,1848. A dramatic poem founded on the story of St.Elizabeth’s life.

317

On Hilarius, an English monk, author of several plays, see Morley’s “Writers before Chaucer.” London,1864, pp.542-552.

318

Delepierre, “History of Flemish Literature from the 12thCentury.” London,1860.

319

Cooper, “Flagellation and the flagellants.” London, 1873.

320

Perrin, “History of the Vaudois.” London,1624.

Muston, “Israel of the Alps.” 2vols., Glasgow,1858.

Monastier, “History of the Vaudois Church from its Origin.” New York,1849.

Peyran, “Historical Defence of the Waldenses or Vaudois.” London,1826.

Todd, “The Waldensian Manuscripts.” London,1865.

Wylie, “History of the Waldensians.” London,1880.

Comba, “History of the Waldenses.” London,1888.

321

Sismondi, “History of Crusades against the Albigenses of the 13thCentury.” London,1826.

322

Limborch, “History of the Inquisition.” 2vols., London,1731.

Lea, “History of the Inquisition.” 3vols., Philad. and London,1888.

Baker, “History of Inquisition in Portugal, Spain, Italy.” Etc., London,1763.

Prescott, “History of Ferdinand and Isabella.” Pt.i., ch.vii.

Llorente, “Histoire critique de l’Inquisition d’Espagne.” Paris,1818.

Rule, “History of Inquisition.” 2vols., London,1874.

323

Creighton, “History of the Papacy during the Reformation.” Vols.i.-iv., A.D.1378-1518, London,1882ff.

Gosselin, “The Power of the Popes during the Middle Ages.” 2vols., London,1853.

Reichel, “See of Rome in the Middle Ages.” London,1870.

324

On BonifaceVIII. see a paper in Wiseman’s “Essays on Various Subjects.” London,1888.

325

Lenfant, “History of the Council of Constance.” 2vols., London,1730.

326

Jenkins, “The Last Crusader; or, The Life and Times of Cardinal Julian of the House of Cesarini.” London,1861.

Creighton, “History of the Papacy.” Vol.ii., “The Council of Basel: the Papal Restoration, A.D.1418-1464.”

327

Creighton, “History of the Papacy.” Vols.iii. andiv., “The Italian Princes, A.D.1464-1518.”

328

Roscoe, “Life and Pontificate of LeoX.” 4vols., Liverpool,1805.

329

Salmon, “The Infallibility of the Church.” London,1888.

330

Haye, “Persecution of the Knights Templars.” Edin.,1865.

331

Kettlewell, “Thomas ÀKempis and the Brothers of the Common Life.” 2vols., London,1882.

332

Hook, “Lives of Archbishops of Canterbury.” Vol.iv., “Bradwardine.”

333

Ueberweg, “History of Philosophy.” Vol.i., pp.460-464.

334

Luther’s Catholic opponents said, Si Lyra non lyrasset, Lutherus non saltasset. This saying had an earlier form: “Si Lyra non lyrasset, nemo Doctorum in Biblia saltasset;” “Si Lyra non lyrasset, totus mundus delirasset.”

335

Dalgairns, “The German Mystics in the 14thCentury.” London,1850.

Vaughan, “Hours with the Mystics.” 3rded., 2vols., London,1888.

336

See an admirable account of Eckhart by Dr.Adolf Lasson in Ueberweg’s “History of Philosophy.” Vol.i., pp.467-484.

337

Winkworth, “Life and Times of Tauler, with Twenty-five Sermons.” London,1857.

Herrick, “Some Heretics of Yesterday.” London,1884.

338

Kettlewell, “The Authorship of the ‘Imitation of Christ.’” London,1877.

Kettlewell, “Thomas À Kempis and the Brothers of the Common Life.” 2vols., London,1882.

Ullmann, “Reformers before the Reformation.” Vol.ii., Edin.,1855.

Cruise, “Thomas À Kempis: Notes of a Visit to the Scenes of his Life.” London,1887.

339

Baring-Gould, “MediÆval Preachers: Some Account of Celebrated Preachers of the 15th, 16th, and 17thCenturies.” London, 1865.

340

“Biblia Pauperum.” Reproduced in facsimile from MS. in British Museum, London,1859.

341

Douce, “The Dance of Death.” London,1833.

342

Symonds, “Renaissance in Italy.” 2vols., London,1881.

343

Church, “Dante and other Essays.” London,1888.

Plumptre, “Commedia, etc., of Dante, with Life and Studies.” 2vols., London,1886-1888.

Oliphant, “Dante.” Edinburgh,1877.

Ozanam, “Dante and the Catholic Philosophy of the 13thCentury.” London,1854.

Barlow, “Critical, Historical, and Philosophical Contributions to the Study of the Divina Commedia.” London,1884.

Botta, “Dante as Philosopher, Patriot, and Poet.” NewYork,1865.

M. F. Rossetti, “A Shadow of Dante.” Boston,1872.

344

Reeve, “Petrarch.” Edinburgh,1879.

Simpson, article on Petrarch in Contemporary Review for July,1874.

345

Wratislaw, “Life and Legend of St.John Nepomucen.” Lon.,1873.

346

Gairdner and Spedding, “Studies in English History.”I., “TheLollards.”

347

Baker, “History of the Inquisition in Portugal, Spain, Italy.” Etc., London,1763.

Llorente, “History of the Inquisition from its Establishment to FerdinandVII.” Philadelphia,1826.

Mocatta, “Jews in Spain and Portugal, and the Inquisition.” London,1877.

348

Lewis, “Hist. of Life and Sufferings of John Wiclif.” Lond.,1720.

Vaughan, “John de Wycliffe. A Monograph.” London,1853.

Lechler, “John Wiclif and his English Precursors.” 2vols., London,1878.

Buddensieg, “John Wyclif, Patriot and Reformer; his Life and Writings.” London,1884.

Burrows, “Wiclif’s Place in History.” London,1882.

Storrs, “John Wycliffe and the first English Bible.” NewYork,1880.

349

Gillet, “Life and Times of John Huss.” Boston, 2vols.,1870.

Wratislaw, “John Huss.” London,1882.

350

Palacky, “Documenta Mag. J.H., Vitam, Doctrinam, Causam.” Etc., illust., Prag.,1869.

Gillett, “Life and Times of John Huss.” 2vols., Boston,1863.

Loserth, “Wiclif and Huss.” London,1884.

351

On these three consult

Ullmann, “Reformers before the Reformation.” 2vols., Edin.,1855.

Brandt, “History of the Reformation in the Low Countries.” Vol.i., London,1720.

352

Heraud, “Life and Times of Savonarola.” London,1843.

Villari, “History of Savonarola.” 2vols., London,1888.

Madden, “The Life and Martyrdom of Savonarola.” 2vols., London,1854.

MacCrie, “History of Reformation in Italy.” Edin.,1827.

Roscoe, “Lorenzo de Medici.” London,1796.

See also chapters on Savonarola in Mrs. Oliphant’s “Makers of Florence.” London,1881.

Milman, “Savonarola, Erasmus.” Etc., Essays, London,1870.

353

Roscoe, “LeoX.” London,1805.

354

Villari, “Niccolo Macchiavelli, and his Times.” 4vols., Lond.,1878.

355

Strauss, “Ulrich von Hutten.” Trans. by Mrs.Sturge, London,1874.

Hausser, “Period of the Reformation.” 2vols., London,1873.

356 A young Minorite, Conrad Pellicanus of TÜbingen, had as early as A.D.1501 composed a very creditable guide to the study of the Hebrew language, under the title De modo legendi et intelligendi HebrÆum, which was first printed in Strassburg in A.D.1504. Amid inconceivable difficulties, purely self taught, and with the poorest literary aids, he had secured a knowledge of the Hebrew language which he perfected by unwearied application to study and by intercourse with a baptized Jew. He attained such proficiency, that he won for himself a place among the most learned exegetes of the Reformed Church as professor of theology at Basel in A.D.1523 and at ZÜrich from A.D.1525 till his death, in A.D.1556. His chief work is Commentaria Bibliorum, 7vols.fol., 1532-1539.
357

Strauss, “Ulrich von Hutten.” London,1874, pp.120-140.

358

Erasmus, “Colloquies.” Trans. by Bailey, ed.by Johnson, Lond.,1877.

“Praise of Folly.” Trans. by Copner, Lond.,1878.

Seebohm, “Oxford Reformers of 1498: Colet, Erasmus, and More.” Lond.,1869.

Drummond, “Erasmus, His Life and Character.” 2vols., Lond.,1873.

Pennington, “Life and Character of Erasmus.” Lond.,1874.

Strauss, “Ulrich von Hutten.” Lond.,1874, pp.315-346.

Dorner, “Hist. of Prot. Theology.” 2vols., Edin.,1871, vol.i., p.202.

359

Seebohm, “Oxford Reformers.” Lond.,1869.

Walter, “Sir Thomas More.” Lond.,1840.

Mackintosh, “Life of Sir Thomas More.” Lond.,1844.

360

Beard, “The Reformation of the 16thCent. in its Relation to Modern Thought and Knowledge.” Lond.,1883.

Wylie, “History of Protestantism.” 3vols., Lond.,1875.

Merle d’AubignÉ, “History of Reformation in the 16thCent. in Switzerland and Germany.” 5vols., Lond.,1840.

D’AubignÉ, “History of Reformation in Times of Calvin.” 8vols., Lond.,1863.

Ranke, “History of Reformation in Germany.” 3vols., Lond.,1845.

HÄusser, “The Period of the Reformation.” 2vols., Lond.,1873.

Hagenbach, “History of the Reformation.” 2vols., Edinburgh,1878.

KÖstlin, “Life of Martin Luther.” Lond.,1884.

Bayne, “Martin Luther: his Life and Work.” 2vols., Lond.,1887.

Rae, “Martin Luther, Student, Monk, Reformer.” Lond.,1884.

Dale, “Protestantism: Its Ultimate Principle.” Lond., 1875.

Dorner, “History of Protestant Theology.” 2vols., Edinburgh,1871.

Cunningham, “Reformers and the Theology of the Reformation.” Edinburgh,1862.

Tulloch, “Leaders of the Reformation.” Edinburgh,1859.

361

Ledderhose, “Life of Melanchthon.” Trans. by Krotel, Philad.,1855.

362

Dorner, “History of Protestant Theology.” Vol.i., pp.98-113.

“The First Principles of the Reformation Illustrated in the Ninety-five Theses and Three Primary Works of Martin Luther.” Edited with historical and theological introductions by Wace and Bucheim, Lond.,1884.

363

Morris, “Luther at the Wartburg and Coburg.” Philad.,1882.

364

Weber, “Luther’s Treatise, De Servo Arbitrio.” In Brit. and For. Evan. Review,1878, pp.799-816.

365

Myconius, “Vita Zwinglii.” Basel,1536.

Hess, “Life of Zwingli, the Swiss Reformer.” London,1832.

Christoffel, “Zwingli; or, The Rise of the Reformation in Switzerland.” Edin.,1858.

Blackburn, “Ulrich Zwingli.” London,1868.

366

Blackburn, “William Farel (1487-1531): The Story of the Swiss Reformation.” Edin.,1867.

367

Burrage, “History of the Anabaptists in Switzerland.” Philad.,1882.

368

Cunningham, “Reformers and Theology of the Reformation.” Edin.,1862, pp.212-291; “Zwingli and the Doctrine of the Sacraments.”

369

Calvin, “Tracts relating to the Reformation, with Life of Calvin by Beza.” 3vols., Edinburgh,1844-1851.

Henry, “Life of John Calvin.” 2vols., London,1849.

Audin (Cath.), “History of Life, Writings, and Doctrines of Calvin.” 2vols., London,1854.

Dyer, “The Life of John Calvin.” London,1850.

Bungener, “Calvin: his Life, Labours, and Writings.” Edinburgh,1863.

370

M’Crie, “The Early Years of John Calvin, A.D.1509-1536.” Ed.by W.Fergusson, Edinburgh,1880.

371

“English Translation of Calvin’s Works.” By Calvin Translation Society, in 52vols., Edinburgh, 1842-1853.

For a more sympathetic and true estimate of Calvin as a commentator, see Farrar, “History of Interpretations.” London,1886.

Also papers by Farrar on the “Reformers as Commentators.” In Expositor, SecondSeries.

372

See Dorner, “History of Protestant Theology.” Vol.i., pp.384-414, for a much truer outline of Calvin’s doctrine from another Lutheran pen.

373

Cunningham, “Reformers and Theology of the Reformation.” Essayvii., “Calvin and Beza.” Pp.345-412, Edin.,1862.

374

Butler, “The Reformation in Sweden, its Rise, Progress, and Crisis, and its Triumph under CharlesIX.” NewYork,1883.

Geijer, “History of the Swedes.” Trans. from the Swedish by Turner, Lond.,1847.

375

Pontoppidan, “Annales eccles. Dan.” ii.,iii., Han.,1741.

Ranke, “History of the Reformation.” Vol.iii.

376

The chief documentary authorities for the whole period are the State Papers edited by Brewer and others. Seealso

Froude, “History of England from Fall of Wolsey till Death of Elizabeth.” 12vols., Lond., 1856-1869.

Burnet, “History of Reformation of Church of England.” 2vols., Lond.,1679.

Blunt, “Reformation of the Church of England.” 4thed., Lond.,1878.

Strype, “Ecclesiastical Memorials.” 3vols., Lond.,1721.

“Annals of the Reformation.” 4vols., 1709-1731.

Foxe, “Acts and Monuments.” (Pub. A.D.1563), 8vols., Lond., 1837-1841.

377

Demaus, “Life of William Tyndal.” London,1868.

Fry, “A Bibliographical Description of the Editions of the N.T., Tyndale’s Version in English, etc., the notes in full of the Edition of1534.” London,1878.

“Facsimile Edition of Tyndale’s first printed N.T.” Edited by Arber, London,1871.

378

Gasquet, “Henry VIII. and the English Monasteries.” 2vols., London,1888.

379

Hook, “Lives of Archb. of Canterbury.” Vols. vi.,vii.

Bayly, “Life and Death of Fisher, Bishop of Rochester.” London,1655.

Dixon, “History of Church of England.” London,1878, vol.i., “HenryVIII.”

Froude, “History of England.” Vols.i.-iii.

380

Heppe, “The Reformers of England and Germany in the Sixteenth Century; their Intercourse and Correspondence.” London,1859.

381

Phillip, “History of the Life of Reg. Pole.” 2vols., London,1765.

Hook, “Lives of Archb. of Cant.” Vol.viii.

Lee, “Reginald Pole, Cardinal-Archbishop of Canterbury: an Historical Sketch.” London,1888.

382

Demaus, “Life of Latimer.” London,1869.

383

Hayward, “Life of EdwardVI.” London,1630.

Hook, “Lives of Archb. of Cant.” Vols.vii. andviii.

Froude, “History of Eng.” Vols.iv. andv.

Strype, “Life of Cranmer.” London,1694.

Norton, “Life of Archb. Cranmer.” New York,1863.

Foxe, “Acts and Monuments.”

Maitland, “Essays on the Reformation in England.” London,1849.

384

Procter, “History of Book of Common Prayer.” Cambr.,1855.

Hole, “The Prayer Book.” London,1887.

Hardwick, “History of the Articles of Religion.” Cambr.,1851.

Stephenson, “Book of Common Prayer.” 3vols., London,1854.

Burnet, “Exposition of the Thirty-Nine Articles.” London,1699.

Browne, “Exposition of Thirty-Nine Articles.” London,1858.

385

Froude, “History of England.” Vols.vi.-xii.

Hook, “Lives of Archb. of Cant.” Vol.ix.

386

Killen, “Ecclesiastical History of Ireland from Earliest to Present Times.” 2vols., Lond.,1875.

Mant, “Hist. of Church of Ireland from Reformation.” London,1839.

Ball, “Hist. of the Church of Ireland.”

387

Lorimer, “Patrick Hamilton, First Preacher and Martyr of the Scottish Reformation.” Edinburgh,1857.

388

It was certainly at St.Andrews that the execution took place. The best and fullest account of Walter Mill is given by Mr.Scott, of Arbroath, in his “Martyrs of Angus and Mearns.” London,1885, pp.210-271.

For George Wishart, see same book, pp.99-209; and

Rogers, “Life of George Wishart.” Edinburgh, 1876.

389

Strickland, “Life of Mary Stuart.” 5vols., Lond.,1875.

Hosack, “Mary Queen of Scots and Her Accusers.” 2vols., Lond.,1874.

Schiern, “Life of James Hepburn, Earl of Bothwell, from the Danish.” Edin.,1880.

Skelton, “Maitland of Lethington and the Scotland of Mary Stuart.” 2vols., Edin.,1887f.

390

“The Works of John Knox.” Collected and edited by David Laing, 7vols., Edin.,1846-1864.

M’Crie, “Life of Knox.” 2vols., Edin.,1811.

Lorimer, “John Knox and the Church of England.” Lond.,1875.

Calderwood, “History of Church of Scotland.” Lond.,1675.

Stuart, “History of Reformation in Scotland.” Lond.,1780.

Cook, “History of Church of Scot. from Ref.” 3vols., Edin.,1815.

M’Crie, “Sketches of Scottish Church History.” 2vols., Lond.,1841.

Cunningham, “History of the Church of Scotland.” 2vols., Edin.,1859.

Lee, “Lectures on History of Church of Scotland from Ref. to Rev.” 2vols., Edin.,1860.

General Histories of Scotland:

“Robertson.” 2vols., Edin.,1759.

“Tytler.” 9vols., Edin.,1826.

“Burton.” 8vols., Edin.,1873.

“Mackenzie.” Edin.,1867.

391

Brandt, “History of the Reformation in the Low Countries.” 4vols., Lond.,1720.

Motley, “Rise of the Dutch Republic.” 3vols., Lond.,1856.

392

Bersier, “Coligny: the Earlier Life of the Great Huguenot.” Lond.,1884.

White, “The Massacre of St.Bartholomew.” 2vols., London,1868.

Lord Mahon, “Life of Louis, Prince of CondÉ.” NewYork,1848.

Baird, “History of the Rise of the Huguenots.” 2vols., London and NewYork,1880.

393

The following have been translated into English:

“Treatise on the Church.” London,1579.

“The Truth of the Christian Religion, partly by Sir Phil. Sydney.” London,1587.

“On the Eucharist.” London,1600.

394

De Felice, “History of Protestants in France from Beginning of Reformation to the Present Time.” London,1853.

Jervis, “History of the Gallican Church from A.D.1516 to the Revolution.” 2vols., London,1872.

Baird, “Huguenots and Henry of Navarre.” 2vols., NewYork,1886.

Ranke, “Civil Wars and Monarchy in France in the 16th and 17thCenturies.” 2vols., London,1852.

Smedley, “History of the Reformation in France.” 3vols., London,1832.

Weiss, “History of the Protestant Reformation in France.” 2vols., London and NewYork,1854.

“Memoirs of Duke of Sully, Prime Minister to HenryIV.” 4vols., London(Bohn).

395

Dalton, “John À Lasco: His Earlier Life and Labours.” London,1886.

Krasinski, “Historical Sketch of the Rise, Progress, and Decline of the Reformation in Poland.” 2vols., London,1838.

396

“History of Persecutions in Bohemia from A.D.894 to A.D.1632.” London,1650.

397

Bauhoffer, “History of the Protestant Church of Hungary, from the beginning of the Reformation to1850, with Reference also to Transylvania.” Trans. by Dr.Craig of Hamburg, with introd. by D’AubignÉ, Lond.,1854.

398

Bochmer, “Spanish Reformers, Lives and Writings.” 2vols., Strassburg,1874.

M’Crie, “History of the Progress and Suppression of Reformation in Spain.” Edin.,1829.

De Castro, “The Spanish Protestants, and their Persecutions by PhilipII.” Lond.,1852.

Prescott, “History of the Reign of PhilipII.” 3vols., Boston,1856.

399

M’Crie, “History of the Progress and Suppression of the Reformation in Italy.” 2nded., Edinburgh,1833.

Wiffen, “Life and Writings of Juan Valdez.” London,1865.

Young, “Life and Times of Aonio Paleario.” 2vols., London,1860.

400

Benrath, “Bernardius Ochino of Siena.” London,1876.

Gordon, “Bernardius Tommassini (Ochino).” In Theological Review for October,1876, pp.532-561.

401

Bonnet, “Life of Olympia Morata: an Episode of the Renaissance and the Reformation in Italy.” Edin.,1854.

402

Krauth, “The Conservative Reformation and its Theology.” Philadelphia,1872.

DÖllinger, “The Church and the Churches.” Lond.,1862.

403

Dorner, “History of Protestant Theology.” Vol.i., pp.338-383.

404

Calvin, “Institutes.” Bk.iii., ch.xi.5-12.

Ritschl, “History of the Christian Doctrine of Justification and Reconciliation.” Edin.,1872, pp.214-233.

405

All the hymns of Luther quoted above are translated by George Macdonald in his “Luther the Singer.” Contributed to the Sunday Magazine for1867.

406

On Speratus, Decius, and Eber, see an interesting paper by the late Dr.Fleming Stevenson in Good Words for1863, p.542.

407

All the hymns referred to above, as well as those which are given in the next paragraph, are translations by Miss Winkworth in “Lyra Germanica.” New edition, London,1885.

408

Warneck, “Outlines of the History of Protestant Missions from the Reformation to the Present Time.” Edinburgh,1884.

409

Hodge, “The Church and its Polity.” Edin.,1879, page114.

410

Morley, “Clement Marot.” London,1871.

411

Lee, “The Church under Queen Elizabeth.” 2vols., London,1880.

M’Crie, “Annals of English Presbytery from the Earliest Period to the Present Time.” London,1872.

412

Neal, “History of the Puritans.” 4vols., London,1731.

Paul, “Life of Whitgift.” London,1699.

Brook, “Lives of the Puritans.” 3vols., London,1813.

Marsden, “The Early Puritans.” London,1852; “The Later Puritans.” London,1853.

Hopkins, “The Puritans.” 3vols., London,1860.

Walker, “History of Independency.” 3vols., London,1648.

Hanbury, “Memorials relating to the Independents.” 3vols., London,1839.

Fletcher, “History of Independ. in England.” 4vols., London,1862.

Waddington, “Congregational History.” London,1874.

Dexter, “The Congregationalism of the last Three Hundred Years, as seen in its Literature.” London,1880.

Marshall, “History of the Mar-Prelate Controversy.” London,1845.

Robinson, “Apologie, or Defence of Christians called Brownists.”1604.

Ashton, “Works of John Robinson, Pastor of Pilgrim Fathers, with Memoir and Annotations.” 3vols., London,1851.

Mather, “Ecclesiastical History of New England, from its Planting in1620 till1698.” London,1702.

Doyle, “The English in America: The Puritan Colonies.” 2vols., London,1888.

Bancroft, “History of the United States.”

413

Parkman, “Pioneers of France in the New World.” London,1885.

Baird, “Rise of the Huguenots of France.” Vol.i., p.291ff.

414

The “Heidelberg Catechism” was translated into English, and published at Oxford,1828.

Ursinus’ expositions of the catechism have been translated: “The Summe of Christian Religion.” Etc., Lond.,1611.

415

An English translation of Erastus’ treatise was published in1699, and re-issued with a preface by Dr.Rob.Lee, Edin.,1844.

One of the fullest and ablest statements on “The Erastian Controversy” is that given in chap. xxvii. of Principal Cunningham’s “Historical Theology.” (Edin.,1870), vol.ii., pp.557-587.

416

Dorner, “History of Protestant Theology.” Vol.i., pp.182-189: “The False Theoretical Mystics: Schwenkfeld.”

Ritschl, “History of the Chr. Doctr. of Justification and Reconciliation.” Edinburgh,1872, p.292.

417

Morley, “Life of Agrippa von Nettesheim.” 2vols., London,1856.

418

Symmonds, “The Age of the Despots.”

Dorner, “History of Protestant Theology.” Vol.i., pp.191-195.

See also two articles in the July and October parts of the Scottish Review for1888, pp.67-107, 244-270: “Giordano Bruno before the Venetian Inquisition,” and “The Ultimate Fate of Giordano Bruno.”

419

More, “Mystery of Godliness.” Bk.vi., chaps.xii.-xviii. Also Enthusiasmus Triumphatus in his “Coll. Phil. Works.” London,1662.

Rutherford, “A Survey of the Spiritual Antichrist, opening the Secrets of Familism and Antinomianism.” London,1648.

420

Mosheim, “Ecclesiastical History.” Cent.xvi., sect.iii., partii., chap.iii.

Ranke, “History of the Reformation.” Vol.iii., bk.vi., chap.ix.

Brandt, “History of the Reformation in the Low Countries.” Vol.i.

421

Burrage, “History of the Anabaptists in Switzerland.” Philadelphia,1882.

Wallace, “Antitrinitarian Biography.” 3vols., London,1850.

Dorner, “Hist. Dev. of Doctr. of Person of Christ.”

Ritschl, “Hist. of Chr. Doctr. of Justification.” P.289.

423

The sketch of Servetus given above is based upon the one-sided and wholesale eulogies of his resolute apologist Tollin.

A thoroughly impartial and objective statement of his doctrinal system is given by Dorner, “History of Prot. Theology.” Vol.i., pp.189-191.

Principal Cunningham, in a very thorough manner, examines the grounds upon which his enemies seek to fix upon Calvin the odium of Servetus’ death in “Reformers and Theology of Reformation.” EssayVI., pp.314-333.

Rilliet, “Calvin and Servetus.” Trans. by Dr.Tweedie, Edinburgh,1846.

Drummond, “Life of Servetus.” London,1848.

Willis, “Servetus and Calvin.” London,1876.

424

Aretius, “History of Val. Gentilis, the Tritheist, put to Death at Bern.” London,1696.

425

Toulmin, “Memoirs of the Life, Char., etc., of Faustus Socinus.” London,1777.

426

Ritschl, “Hist. of Chr. Doctr. of Justification.” Pp.298-309.

Cunningham, “Historical Theology.” Chap.xxiii., “The Socinian Controversy,” pp.155-236.

Stillingfleet gives an account of the Racovian Catechism in the preface to his work on “Christ’s Satisfaction.” 2nded., London,1697.

427

Ranke, “History of the Popes.” Bk.ii., “Beginnings of a Regeneration of Catholicism.”

428

Pasquino was a statue which shortly before had been dug up and placed on the spot where formerly had stood the booth of a cobbler of that name, dreaded for his pungent wit. It was used for the posting up of “pasquins” of every sort, especially about the popes and the curia.

429

An admirable paper by Hase on Theiner’s “Acts of the Council of Trent” has been translated in the Brit. and For. Evan. Review for1876, pp.358-369.

Mendham, “Memoirs of the Council of Trent.” London,1834.

Father Paul Sarpi’s “History of the Council of Trent.” 3rded.fol., London,1640.

Bungener, “History of the Council of Trent.” Edin.,1852.

Buckley, “Canons and Decrees of Council of Trent.” London,1851.

Buckley, “Catechism of Council of Trent.” London,1852.

430

Mendham, “The Life and Pontificate of PiusV.” London,1832.

431

HÜbner, “The Life and Times of SixtusV.” Trans. by Jerningham, 2vols., London,1872.

432

In “Spanish Mystics.” (London,1886), there is an admirable sketch of Theresa, pp.39-86, and of John of the Cross, pp.106-113.

433

“Spanish Mystics.” P.7,note.

434

“Life of St.Philip Neri, Apostle of Rome, and Founder of the Congregation of the Oratory.” 2vols., London,1847.

435

Coleridge, “Life of Ignatius Loyola.” London,1872.

Ranke, “History of the Popes.” Vol.i.

436

Rose, “Ignatius Loyola, and the Early Jesuits.” London,1870.

Nicolini, “History of the Jesuits.” Edin.,1853.

Sir James Stephens on “The Founders of Jesuitism.” In his “Essays on Ecclesiastical Biography.” Vol.i., p.249.

437

Cartwright, “The Jesuits, their Constitution and Teaching.” London,1876.

438

Griesinger, “The Jesuits: from the Foundation of the Order to the Present Time.” London,1885.

Pascal, “Provincial Letters.” Translated by Dr.M’Crie, Edin.,1851.

“The Jesuits’ Morals, collected out of the Jesuit’s own Books.” London,1670.

439

Gibbings, “An Exact Reprint of the Roman Index Expurgatorius.” The only Vatican Index of this kind ever published. Dublin,1837.

440

Butler, “Life of Cardinal Borromeo.” London,1835.

Martin, “Life of Borromeo.” London,1847.

441

Venn, “Missionary Life and Labours of Xavier.” Lond.,1863.

442

Legge, “Christianity in China: Nestorianism, Roman Catholicism, Protestantism; with the Chinese and Syriac Texts of the Nestorian Monument of Hsi-an-FÛ.” London,1888.

443

Adams, “History of Japan from the Earliest Period.” 2vols., London,1874.

On the religion of Japan before the introduction of Christianity, see Ebrard, “Apologetics.” Vol.iii., pp.66-73, Edin.,1887.

444

Helps, “Life of Barth. de las Casas.” 2nded., Lond.,1868.

Prescott, “History of Conquest of Mexico.” London,1886, pp.178-184.

445

MerimÉe, “The Russian Impostors: the False Demetrius.” London,1852.

446

Neale, “History of the Holy Eastern Church.” Vol.ii., p.356ff.

Cyrillus Lucaris, “Confessio ChristianÆ Fidei.” Geneva,1633.

Smith, “Collectanea de Cyrillo Lucario.” London,1707.

447

Stevens, “Life and Times of Gustavus Adolphus.” NewYork,1884.

Trench, “Gustavus Adolphus in Germany, and other Lectures on the Thirty Years’ War.” London.

Gardiner, “The Thirty Years’ War” in “Epochs of Modern History.” London,1881.

448

Bray, “Revolt of the Protestants of the Cevennes.” London,1870.

Poole, “History of the Huguenots of the Dispersion.” London,1880.

Agnew, “Protestant Exiles from France in the Reign of LouisXIV.” 3vols., London,1871.

Weiss, “History of French Protestant Refugees.” London,1854.

449

Macaulay, “History of England from the Accession of JamesII.” London,1846.

Hassencamp, “History of Ireland from the Reformation to the Union.” London,1888.

Adair, “Rise and Progress of the Presbyterian Church of Ireland from1623 to1670.” Belfast,1866.

Hamilton, “History of Presbyterian Church in Ireland.” Edin.,1887.

450

Butler, “Life of Hugo Grotius.” London,1826.

Motley, “John of Barneveld.” Vol.ii., New York,1874.

451

“An Exposition of the Doctrine of the Catholic Church in Matters of Controversy.” London,1685.

“Variations of Protestantism.” 2vols., Dublin,1836.

Butler, “Some Account of the Life and Writings of Bishop Bossuet.” London,1812.

452

“The Work of John Durie in behalf of Christian Union in the Seventeenth Century.” By Dr.Briggs in Presbyterian Review, vol.viii., 1887, pp.297-300. To which is attached an account by Durie himself, never before published, of his own union efforts from July,1631, till September,1633. See pp.301-309.

453

Clarendon, “History of the Rebellion in England, 1649-1666.” 3vols., Oxford,1667.

Burnet, “History of his Own Time, 1660-1713.” 2vols., London,1724.

Guizot, “History of English Revolution of1640.” London,1856.

Gardiner, “History of England, 1603-1642.” 10vols., London,1885.

Marsden, “History of Early and Later Puritans, down to the Ejection of the Nonconformists in1662.” 2vols., London,1853.

Masson, “Life of Milton.” 4vols., London,1859ff.

454

Mitchell, “The Westminster Assembly.” London,1882.

Mitchell and Struthers, “Minutes of Westminster Assembly.” Edinburgh,1874.

Macpherson, “Handbook to Westminster Confession.” 2nded., Edinburgh,1882.

Hetherington, “History of Westminster Assembly.” 4thed., Edinburgh,1878.

455

Carlyle, “Cromwell’s Letters and Speeches.” 2vols., London,1845.

Guizot, “Life of Cromwell.” London,1877.

Paxton Hood, “Oliver Cromwell.” London,1882.

Picton, “Oliver Cromwell.” London,1878.

Harrison, “Oliver Cromwell.” London,1888.

Barclay, “The Inner Life of the Religious Societies of the Commonwealth.” London,1877.

456

Guizot, “Richard Cromwell and the Restoration of CharlesII.” 2vols., London,1856.

Macpherson, “History of Great Britain from the Restoration.” London,1875.

457

Bargraves, “AlexanderVII. and His Cardinals.” Ed.by Robertson, London,1866.

458

Cunningham, “Discussions on Church Principles.” Edin.,1863, chap.v.: “The Liberties of the Gallican Church.” Pp.133-163.

459

Von Gebler, “Galileo Galilei and the Roman Curia.” Transl. by Sturge, London,1879.

Madden, “Galileo and the Inquisition.” London,1863.

Brewster, “Martyrs of Science.” Edin.,1841.

Von Gebler denies that any condemnation ex cathedra wasgiven.

460

Wilson, “Life of Vincent de Paul.” London,1874.

461

Marsolier, “Life of Francis de Sales.” Translated by Coombes, London,1812.

462

“Golden Thoughts from the ‘Spiritual Guide’ of Molinos.” With preface by J.H. Shorthouse, London,1883.

463

Upham, “Life, Religious Opinions, and Experience of Madame de la Mothe Guyon, with an account of FÉnelon.” London,1854.

Brooke, “Exemplary Life of the Pious Lady Guion.” Bristol,1806.

Butler, “Life of FÉnelon.” London,1810.

464

Beard, “Port Royal.” 2vols., London,1861.

St.Amour, “Journal in France and Rome, containing Account of Five Points of Controversy between Jansenists and Molinists.” London,1664.

Schimmelpenninck, “Select Memoirs of Port Royal.” Fourth edition, 2vols., London,1835.

465

Dorner, “History of Protestant Theology.” Vol.ii., pp.98-251.

466

Bruce, “Humiliation of Christ.” P.131, Edin.,1876.

467

Dowding, “German Theology during the Thirty Years’ War: Life and Correspondence of G.Calixt.” 2vols., Oxford,1863.

468

Wildenhahn, “Life of Spener.” Translated by Wenzel, Philadelphia,1881.

Guericke, “Life of A.H. Francke.” London,1847.

469

Jennings, “The Rosicrucians: their Rites and Mysteries.” London,1887.

470

Martensen, “Life and Works of Jacob Boehme.” London,1886.

471

All the translations of hymns referred to in this and the preceding section are from Miss Winkworth’s “Lyra Germanica.” London,1885.

472

The “Works of Arminius.” Transl. by Nicholls, to which are added Brandt’s “Life of Arminius.” Etc., 3vols., London,1825.

Scott, “Translation of Articles of Synod of Dort.” London,1818.

Hales, “Letters from the Synod of Dort.” Glasgow,1765.

Calder, “Life of Simon Episcopius.” NewYork,1837.

Cunningham, “Reformation and Theology of Reformation.” EssayVIII., “Calvinism and Arminianism.” Pp.412-470.

Motley, “John of Barneveldt.” 2vols., London,1874.

473

Barclay, “The Inner Life of the Religious Societies of the Commonwealth.” Seconded., London,1877.

Dr. Stoughton’s “History of Religion in England from Opening of Long Parliament to End of Eighteenth Century.” London.

474

See Macpherson, “Presbyterianism.” (Edin.,1883), pp.8-10, where charges of intolerance such as those made against Presbyterianism in the text are repudiated.

475

Masson, “Life of John Milton.” 4vols., London,1859.

Pattison, “Milton.” In “English Men of Letters” series, London,1880.

476

RelquiÆ BaxterianÆ: Baxter’s Narrative of most Memorable Passages in his own Life.” London,1696.

Orme, “Life and Times of Richard Baxter, with Critical Examination of his Writings.” London,1830.

Stalker, “Baxter” in “Evangelical Succession Lectures.” Second series, Edinburgh,1883.

477

Froude disputes this, and says, p.12, that probably he was on the side of the Royalists. Brown has shown it to be almost certain that in1644, not1642, Bunyan, then in his sixteenth year, joined the Parliamentary forces. See Brown’s “Life.” Pp.42-52.

478

Brown, “Life of Bunyan.” London,1885.

Autobiography in “Grace Abounding.”1622.

Southey, “Life of John Bunyan.” London,1830.

Macaulay, “Essay on Bunyan.” In Edinburgh Review,1830.

Froude, “Bunyan,” in “English Men of Letters.” London,1880.

Nicoll, “Bunyan,” in “Evangelical Succession Lectures.” Third series, Edinburgh,1883.

479

“Life of John Eliot, Apostle of the Indians.” By John Wilson, afterwards of Bombay, Edin.,1828.

480

Crosby, “History of the English Baptists.” 4vols., London,1728.

Ivimey, “History of the English Baptists from 1688-1760.” 2vols., London,1830.

Cramp, “History of the Baptists to end of 18th Century.” 3vols., London,1872.

481

Backus, “History of the English-American Baptists.” 2vols., Boston,1777.

Cox and Hoby, “The Baptists in America.” NewYork,1836.

Hague, “The Baptists Transplanted.” Etc., NewYork,1846.

482

Of special importance for the early history of the Quakers are,

“Letters of Early Friends.” Edited by Robert Barclay, a descendant of the Quaker apostle, London,1841.

“Fox’s Journal; or, Historical Accounts of his Life, Travels, and Sufferings.” London,1694.

Penn, “Summary of History, Doctrines, and Discipline of Friends.” London,1692.

Tallack, “George Fox; the Quakers and the Early Baptists.” London,1868.

Bickley, “George Fox and the Early Quakers.” London,1884.

Stoughton, “W. Penn, Founder of Pennsylvania.” London,1883.

483

Sewel, “History of the Quakers.” 2vols., London,1834.

Cunningham, “The Quakers, from their Origin in1624 to the Present Time.” London,1868.

Barclay, “Apology for the True Christian Divinity: a Vindication of Quakerism.” 4thed., London,1701.

Clarkson, “A Portraiture of Quakerism.” 3vols., London,1806.

Rowntree, “Quakerism, Past and Present.” London,1839.

484

Heard, “The Russian Church and Russian Dissent.” London,1887.

Mackenzie Wallace, “Russia.” Chaps.xiv.,xx., 2vols., London,1877.

Palmer, “The Patriarch and the Tsar.” 6vols., London,1871-1876.

485

Ueberweg, “History of Philosophy.” Vol.ii., pp.31-135.

PÜnjer, “History of the Christian Philosophy of Religion from the Reformation to Kant.” Edin.,1887.

Pfleiderer, “Philosophy of Religion.” Vol.i., London,1887.

Erdmann’s “History of Philosophy.” 3vols., London,1889.

486

“Bacon’s Works.” Ed. by Spedding, Ellis, and Heath, 14vols., London,1870.

Spedding, “Letters and Life of Lord Bacon.” 2vols., London,1862.

Macaulay on Bacon in Edinburgh Review for1837.

Church, “Bacon,” in vol.v. of “Collected Works.” London,1888.

Nichol, “Bacon: Life and Philosophy.” 2 vols., Edin.,1888.

487

“Descartes’ Method, Meditations, and Principles of Philosophy.” Transl. by Prof.Veitch, Edin.,1850ff.

Fischer, “Descartes and his School.” London,1887.

488

Willis, “Spinoza: his Ethics, Life, and Influence on Modern Thought.” London,1870.

Pollock, “Spinoza: his Life and Philosophy.” London,1880.

Martineau, “Spinoza.” London,1882.

“Spinoza, Four Essays by Land, Von Floten, Fischer, and Renan.” Edited by Prof.Knight, London,1884.

489

“Locke’s Complete Works.” 9vols., London,1853.

Cousin, “Elements of Psychology: a Critical Examination of Locke’s Essay.” Edin.,1856.

Webb, “Intellectualism of Locke.” London,1858.

490

Guhrauer, “Leibnitz: a Biography.” Transl. by Mackie, Boston,1845.

491

Leland, “View of Principal Deistical Writers in England.” 2nded., 2vols., London,1755.

Halyburton, “Natural Religion Insufficient; or, A Rational Inquiry into the Principles of the Modern Deists.” Edin.,1714.

Tulloch, “Rational Theology and Christian Philosophy in England in the 17thCentury.” 2vols., Edin.,1872.

Cairns, “Unbelief in the 18thCentury.” Chap.ii., “Unbelief in the 17thCentury.” Edin.,1881.

492

Lecky, “History of the Rise and Influence of the Spirit of Rationalism in Europe.” 2vols., London,1873.

Hagenbach, “German Rationalism.” Edin.,1865.

Hagenbach, “History of Church in 18th and 19thCenturies.” 2vols., London,1870.

Leslie Stephen, “History of English Thought in the 18thCentury.” 2vols., London,1876.

Cairns, “Unbelief in the 18thCentury.” Edin.,1881.

493

Wilson, “The Christian Brothers, their Origin and Work. With a Sketch of the Life of their Founder, the Venerable Jean Baptiste de la Salle.” London,1883.

494

Neale, “History of the so called Jansenist Church of Holland.” Oxford,1858.

495

Cairns, “Unbelief in the Eighteenth Century.” Chap.iv., “Unbelief in France.” Edinburgh,1881.

Morley, “Diderot and the Encyclopedists.” 2vols., London,1878.

Morley, “Voltaire.” London,1872.

Lange, “History of Materialism.” 3vols., London,1877.

496

This saying is usually attributed to Voltaire. He used the expression in attacking Pierre Bayle.

Erdmann’s “Hist. of Phil.” Vol.ii., p.158.

Ueberweg, “Hist. of Phil.” Vol.ii., p.125.

497

PressensÉ, “The Church and the Revolution.” London, 1869.

Jervis, “The Gallican Church and the Revolution.” London,1882.

498

Hagenbach, “History of Church in the 18th and 19thCenturies.” Vol.i., pp.109,116; 2vols., NewYork,1869.

Dorner, “History of Protestant Theology.” Vol.ii., p.208.

499

Dorner, “History of Protestant Theology.” Vol.ii., pp.208-227.

500

Dorner, “History of Protestant Theology.” Vol.ii., pp.266-279.

Hagenbach, “History of Church in 18th and 19thCenturies.” Vol.i., pp.117-127.

501

Dorner, “History of Protestant Theology.” Vol.ii., pp.259-261.

Geffcken, “Church and State.” 2vols., Lon.,1887; vol.i., pp.456-503.

502

Burney, “Life of Handel.” London,1784.

503

Kelly, “Life and Work of Von Bogatsky: a Chapter from the Religious Life of the Eighteenth Century.” London,1889.

504

Hough, “The History of Christianity in India.” 5vols., London,1839.

Sherring, “History of Missions in India.” Edited by Storrow. London,1888.

Pearson, “Memoirs, Life, and Correspondence of Chr.Fr. Schwartz.” Etc., 2vols., London,1834.

505

Hagenbach, “History of the Christian Church in the 18th and 19th Centuries.” New York, 1869; Lectures XVIII. and XIX., pp. 398-445.

506

Spangenberg, “Life of Count Zinzendorf.” London,1838.

507

Spangenberg, “Account of Manner in which the Unitas Fratrum Propagate the Gospel, and Carry on their Missions among the Heathen.” London,1788.

Holmes, “Historical Sketch of the Missions of the United Brethren for the Propagation of the Gospel among the Heathen from their Commencement down to1817.” London,1827.

508

“Tersteegen: Life and Character, with Extracts from His Letters and Writings.” London,1832.

Winkworth, “Christian Singers of Germany.” London,1869.

509

For a slightly different account see Tyerman, vol.i., p.66.

510

Wesley himself continued to preach in the open air till nearly the end of the year1790.

511

Further details as to the organization of the societies are given in Tyerman, 1sted., vol.i., pp.444,445.

512

Southey, “Life of John Wesley.” London,1820.

Isaac Taylor, “Wesley and Wesleyanism.” London,1851.

Tyerman, “Wesley’s Life and Times.” 2vols., 4thed., London,1877.

Urlin, “Churchman’s Life of Wesley.” London,1880.

Abbey and Overton, “English Church in 18thCentury.” 2vols., London,1879.

Lecky, “History of England in the 18thCentury.” 2vols., London,1878.

Stoughton, “History of Religion in England to End of 18thCentury.” 6vols., London,1882.

Jackson, “Life of Charles Wesley.” 2vols., London,1841.

Tyerman, “Life of Whitefield.” 2vols., London,1877.

Macdonald, “Fletcher of Madeley.” London.

Smith, “History of Methodism.” 3vols., London,1857.

Stevens, “History of Methodism.” 3vols., NewYork,1858.

Stevens, “History of the Methodist Episcopal Church in the United States.” 4vols., NewYork,1864.

Bangs, “History of the Methodist Episcopal Church.” 4vols., NewYork,1839.

513

Hagenbach, “History of Church in 18th and 19thCenturies.” Vol.i., pp.159-164.

514

Hagenbach, “History of the Church in the 18th and 19thCenturies.” Vol.i., pp.168-175.

515

Tafel, “Documents concerning the Life and Character of Swedenborg.” 3vols., London,1875.

White, “Emanuel Swedenborg, his Life and Writings.” 2vols., London,1867.

516

Evans, “Shakers: Compendium of Origin, History, Principles, and Doctrines of the United Society of Believers in Christ’s Second Coming.” New York,1859.

Dixon, “New America.” 2vols., 8thed., London,1869.

Nordhoff, “The Communistic Societies of the United States.” London,1874.

517

Pusey, “Historical Inquiry into the Causes of the Prevalence of Rationalism in Germany.” London,1828.

Rose, “The State of Protestantism in Germany.” Oxford,1829.

Saintes, “A Critical History of Rationalism in Germany, from its Origin till the Present Time.” London,1849.

Lecky, “History of the Rise and Influence of the Spirit of Rationalism in Europe.” 2vols., London,1873.

Farrar, “Critical History of Free Thought in Reference to the Christian Religion.” London,1863.

Hagenbach, “German Rationalism.” Edinburgh,1865.

Hurst, “History of Rationalism.” New York,1865.

Gostwick, “German Culture and Christianity, their Controversy, 1770-1880.” NewYork,1882.

518

Stephen, “History of English Thought in the 18th Century.” 2vols., London,1876.

Cairns, “Unbelief in the 18thCentury.” Edinburgh,1881.

PÜnjer, “History of Christian Philosophy of Religion from Reformation to Kant.” §5, “The English Deists.” Edinburgh,1887.

519

Halliwell, “The Early History of English Freemasonry.” London,1840.

520

Ritschl, “History of Christian Doctr. of Justification and Reconciliation.” Pp.347-426.

Dorner, “History of Protestant Theology.” Vol.ii., pp.277-292.

Hagenbach, “History of The Church in The 18th and 19thCenturies.” Vol.i., pp.251-321.

521

ChalybÆus, “Historical Development of Speculative Philosophy, from Kant to Hegel.” Edin.,1854.

RÄbiger, “Theological EncyclopÆdia.” Vol.i., pp.73-76.

522

Stahr, “Lessing: his Life and Works.” Translated by G.Evans, 2vols., Boston,1866.

Sime, “Lessing, his Life and Writings.” 2vols., London,1877.

Zimmern, “G.E. Lessing: his Life and Works.” London,1878.

Smith, “Lessing as a Theologian.” In the Theological Review, July,1868.

523

Russell, “A Short Account of the Life and History of Pestalozzi.” Based on De Guemp’s “L’Histoire de Pestalozzi.” London,1888. To be followed by a complete English translation of De Guemp’s work.

524

Marshman, “Life and Times of Marshman, Carey, and Ward.” 2vols., London,1859.

Smith, “Life of William Carey.” London,1886.

Wilson, “Missionary Voyage of the Ship Duff.” London,1799.

Morison, “Fathers and Founders of the London Missionary Society.” London,1844.

525

Baur, “Religious Life in Germany.” London,1872, pp.177-196.

526

Kahnis, “Internal History of German Protestantism since the Middle of Last Century.” Edin.,1856.

527

Hagenbach, “History of Church in Eighteenth and Nineteenth Centuries.” Vol.ii., pp.413-416.

528

Mombert, “Faith Victorious, being an Account of the Life, Labour, and Times of Dr.J.W.Ebel, 1714-1861, compiled from authentic sources.” London,1882.

Dixon, “Spiritual Wives.” London,1868.

529

Strack, “The Work of Bible Revision in Germany.” In Expositor, third series, vol.ii., pp.178-187.

530

See papers by Driver, Cheyne, Davidson, Kirkpatrick, in Expositor for 1886-1888, on various books in Revised Old Testament.

Westcott, “Some Lessons of Revised Version of New Testament.” In Expositor, third series, vol.v., pp.81, 241,453.

Jennings and Lowe, “Revised Version of Old Testament: a Critical Estimate.” In Expositor, third Series, vol.ii., pp.57,etc.

531

“Schleiermacher’s Life in Letters.” Translated by Rowan, London,1860.

Baur, “Religious Life in Germany.” London,1872, pp.197ff.

Dorner, “History of Protestant Theology.” Vol.ii., pp.374-395.

532

Cheyne, “Life and Works of Heinrich Ewald.” In Expositor, third series, vol.iv., pp.241ff., 361ff.

533

There are English translations of his “Life of Christ.” “First Planting of Christianity.” “Antignostikus.” “History of Christian Dogmas.” “Christian Life in the Early and Middle Ages.” All published byBohn.

534

Zeller, “David Frederick Strauss, in his Life and Writings.” London,1874. Translations: “Life of Jesus Critically Treated.”1846; “Life of Jesus for the German People.”1865; “The Old Faith and the New.”1874; “Ulrich von Hutten.”1874.

535

Simon, “Isaac August Dorner.” In Presbyterian Review for October,1887, pp.569-616.

536

Rothe, “Still Hours.” Translated by MissStoddart, with Introductory Essay on Rothe by Rev.J.Macpherson. London,1886.

537

Galloway, “The Theology of Ritschl.” In Presbyterian Review for April, 1889, pp. 192-209.

538

Series of papers in Good Words for1860, pp.377ff.

539

Fleming Stevenson, “The Blue Flag of Kaiserswerth.” In Good Words for1861, pp.121ff., 143ff.

540

Owen, “History of the First Ten Years of the Bible Society.” 3vols., London,1816.

541

Wiseman, “Recollections of the Last Four Popes.” 3vols., London,1853.

Mendham, “Index of Prohibited Books by order of GregoryXVI.” London,1840.

542

Legge, “Pius IX. to the Restoration of1850.” 2vols., London,1872.

Trollope, “Life of PiusIX.” 2vols., London,1877.

Shea, “Life and Pontificate of PiusIX.” NewYork,1877.

543

Geffcken, “Church and State.” Vol.ii., pp.269-293: “The Italian Question and the Papal States.”

544

Geffcken, “Church and State.” Vol.ii., pp.236-238.

545

Bridges, “Life of Martin Boos.” London,1836.

546

Hamberger, “Sketch of the Character of the Theosophy of Baader.” Translated in American Presbyterian and Theological Review,1869.

547

Laing, “Notes on the Rise, Progress, etc., of the German Catholic Church of Ronge and Czerski.” London,1845.

548

Manning, “The True History of the Vatican Council.” London,1877.

Pomponio Leto, “The Vatican Council, being the impressions of a contemporary (Card. Vitelleschi), translated from the Italian with the original documents.” London,1876.

Quirinus, “Letters from Rome on the Council.” London,1870.

Janus, “The Pope and the Council.” London,1869.

Bungener, “Rome and the Council in the Nineteenth Century.” Edinburgh,1870.

Arthur, “The Pope, the Kings, and the People, a History of the Movement to make the Pope Governor of the World, 1864-1871.” 2vols., London,1877.

Acton, “History of the Vatican Council.” London,1871.

Friedrich, “Documenta ad illum. Conc. Vat.” NÖrdling,1871.

Martin (Bishop of Paderborn), “Omnium Conc. Vat. quÆ ad doctr. et discipl. pertin. docum. Collectio.”1873.

549

Geffcken, “Church and State.” Vol.ii., pp.501-531.

Smith, “The Falk Legislation from the Political Point of View.” In the Theological Review for October,1875.

550

Geffcken, “Church and State.” 2vols., London,1877; vol.ii., pp.488-531.

551— The Austrian May Laws were in some respects more sweeping than the Prussian (§197,5); but the former were framed with reference to the police, the latter with reference to the law. In Prussia the decision, judgment, and sentence in all cases of contravention and collision were assigned to the court of law; in Austria they were assigned to the court of administration, in the last instance to the minister. The Austrian laws could thus be urged and ignored at pleasure. 552

Geffeken, “Church and State.” Vol.ii., pp.469-488.

553

R. J. Sandeman, “Alexander Vinet.” In “Evangelical Succession Lectures.” Third Series, Edinburgh,1884.

Dorner, “History of Protestant Theology.” ii.,470,478.

554

Cairns, “The Present Struggle in the National Church of Holland.” In Presbyterian Review for January,1888, pp.87-108.

Wicksteed, “The Ecclesiastical Institutions of Holland.” London.

555

Lumsden, “Sweden, its Religious State and Prospects.” London,1855.

556

Stoughton, “Religion in England during the First Half of the Present Century, with a Postscript on Subsequent Events.” 2vols., London,1876.

Molesworth, “History of England from1830 to1874.” 3vols., London.

557

Littledale, “Church Parties.” Art. in the Contemporary Review for July,1874, pp.287-320.

Mozley, “Reminiscences of Oriel College.” London,1882.

558

Newman, “Apologia pro Vita Sua.” London,1864.

Weaver, “Puseyism, a Refutation and Exposure.” London,1843.

559

The very confused, wholly inadequate, and in some points positively incorrect statements in the above paragraph may be supplemented and amended by reference to the following literature:

Buchanan, “Ten Years’ Conflict.” 2vols., Edin.,1852.

Moncrieff, “Vindication of the Claim of Right.” Edin.,1877.

Moncrieff, “The Free Church Principle: its Character and History.” Edin.,1883.

Mackerrow, “History of the Secession Church.” Glasgow,1841.

560— Smith’s appointment was to the Lord Almoner’s Professorship, with a merely nominal salary; but he was afterwards elected to the more remunerative office of University librarian, and more recently has succeeded Prof. Wright in the Chair of Arabic in the University. 561

Jarvis, “The Gallican Church and the Revolution.” Pp.324-395, London,1882.

562

Borrow, “The Bible in Spain.” 2vols., London,1843.

563

Lendrum, “Ecclesia Pressa: or, the Lutheran Church in the Baltic Provinces.” In The Theological Review and Free Church College Quarterly, vol.ii., 310-330.

C. H. H. Wright, “The Persecution of the Lutheran Church in the Baltic Provinces of Russia.” In the British and Foreign Evangelical Review, January,1887.

564

Baird, “Religion in the United States.” Glasgow,1844.

“Progress and Prospects of Christianity in the United States.” London,1851.

Gorrie, “Churches and Sects in the United States.” NewYork,1850.

565

Stevens, “History of the Episcopal Methodist Church in North America.” Philadelphia,1868.

Gorrie, “History of the Episcopal Methodist Church in the United States.” NewYork,1881.

566

A full account of the recent development of Protestantism in Brazil is given in an article in the Presbyterian Review for January,1889, pp.101-106: “The Organization of the Synod of Brazil,” by Dr.J. Aspinwall Hodge.—On 15thNovember,1889, the emperor was expelled and a republic proclaimed.

567

Hepworth Dixon, “Free Russia.” 2vols., London,1870.

Heard, “The Russian Church and Russian Dissent.” 2vols., London,1887.

568

Rowntree, “Quakerism Past and Present.” London,1859.

569

Dixon, “New America.” 2vols., 8thedition, London,1869.

Nordhoff, “The Communistic Societies of the United States.” London,1874.

570

Oliphant, “Life of Ed. Irving.” 3rdedition, London,1865.

Carlyle, in “Miscellaneous Essays.”

Brown, “Personal Reminiscences of Ed. Irving.” in Expositor, 3ser., vol.vi., pp.216,257.

Miller, “History and Doctrine of Irvingism.” 2vols., London,1878.

571

Darby, “Personal Recollections.” London,1881.

572

Stenhouse, “An Englishwoman in Utah, the story of a Life’s Experience in Mormonism.” 2nded., London,1880.

Gunnison, “The Mormons.” New York,1884.

Burton, “The City of the Saints.” London,1861.

573

Wilson, “The ‘Ever-Victorious Army:’ a History of the Chinese Campaign under Lieut.-Col. C.G. Gordon, and of the Suppression of the Taeping Rebellion.” Edinburgh.

574

Edmonds, “American Spiritualism.” 2vols., NewYork,1858.

Cox, “Spiritualism answered by Science.” London,1872.

Crookes, “Spiritualism and Science.” London,1874.

Wallace, “A Defence of Spiritualism.” London,1874.

Owen, “The Debatable Land.” NewYork,1872.

Carpenter, “Mesmerism, Spiritualism, etc., Historically and Scientifically Considered.” London,1877.

Mahan, “The Phenomena of Spiritualism Scientifically Explained and Exposed.” London,1875.

Horne, “Incidents in His Life.” London,1863.

“Lights and Shadows of Spiritualism.” London,1877.

575

Sinnett, “Esoteric Buddhism.” London,1883.

576

Sargent, “Rob. Owen and his Social Philosophy.” London,1860.

Nordhoff, “Communistic Societies in the United States.” London,1875.

577

Onslow-Yorke, “The Secret History of the International Working-Men’s Association.” London,1872.

Lissagaray, “History of the Commune of1871.” Translated by Aveling, London,1886.

578— From the fifteenth century the numbering of the General Councils is so variable and uncertain that even Catholic historians are not agreed upon this point. They are at one only about this, that the anti-papal councils claiming to be oecumenical, of Pisa A.D.1409, Basel A.D.1438, and Pisa A.D.1511, should be designated schismatical “Conciliabula.” Hefele, in his “History of the Councils,” counts eighteen down to the Reformation. He makes the Constance Council in its first and last sessions the sixteenth, but does not count the middle session held without the pope. He makes that of Basel the seventeenth down to A.D.1438 with its papal continuation at Ferrara and Florence. Finally, as eighteenth he gives the fifth Lateran Council of A.D.1512-1517. But others strike Basel and Constance out of the list altogether; and many, especially the Gallicans, reject also the fifth Lateran Council, because occupied with matters of slight or merely local interest.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           

Clyx.com


Top of Page
Top of Page