A Republican.

Previous

The State Gazette Of South Carolina, (Number 3610)

Monday, May 5, 1788.

Mrs. Timothy:

The enclosed,64 copied from a paper sent me by a friend, seems so peculiarly adapted to our present situation, that I cannot forbear selecting it from the crowd of publications since the appearance of the proposed Federal Constitution, and recommending it, thro' your paper, to the most serious attention of all our fellow-citizens; but previously a few HINTS, by way of introduction, will not, I hope, be impertinent.

New Hampshire and Georgia are the two extreme barriers of the United States, if the latter can with any propriety be called a barrier without this state in conjunction; and both together, we know, are not, in point of force, ready for any sudden emergency, to be compared to New Hampshire.

It cannot be doubted that Great Britain has her busy emissaries throughout the states, and not a few amongst us; and should the Constitution be rejected, how long can we flatter ourselves to be free from Indian cruelties and depredations, some time since begun in Georgia, and if at this moment warded off from us, 'tis principally owing to the dread of an efficacious union of the states by the adoption of the Federal Constitution. The three southern states particularly, we have had for several years past, good [pg 412] grounds to think Great Britain wishes to separate from the rest, and to have reverted to her if possible.

Mr. Martin's65 long mischievous detail of the opinions and proceedings of the late general convention, (already occupying a large space in six of your Gazettes, and still unfinished,) with all his colourings and uncandid insinuations, in regard to General Washington and Doct. Franklin, may suit the short-sighted selfish wishes of an individual of a state situated almost in the centre of the rest, and much safer by that means from sudden alarms. But the generous, manly and truly federal sentiments of Maryland are well known, and 'tis not doubted will be unequivocally shewn at her convention very shortly to be held—and that New Hampshire, early in her first meeting on that important subject, has only by consent taken farther time to consider of it, and will at her next meeting adopt it, is the general opinion.

What pity the salutary caution of Doct. Franklin, just previous to his signing the constitution recommended by the convention, had not been strictly attended to! If we split, it will in all probability happen in running headlong on the dangerous rock he so prophetically (as it were) warned us from, “That the opinions of the errors of the constitution born within the walls of the convention, should die there, and not a syllable be whispered abroad.” This Hint is full of that foresight and penetration the Doctor has always been remarkable for.

When the general convention met, no citizen of the United States could expect less from it than I did, so many jarring interests and prejudices to reconcile! The variety of pressing dangers at our doors, even during the war, were barely sufficient to force us to act in concert, and necessarily give way at times to each other. But when the great work was done and published, I was not only most agreeably disappointed, but struck with amazement. Nothing less than that superintending hand of Providence, that so miraculously carried us through the war (in my humble opinion), could have brought it about so complete, upon the whole.

[pg 413]

The constitution recommended, in all respects, takes its rise where it ought, from the people; its President, Senate, and House of Representatives, are sufficient and wholesome checks on each other, and at proper periods are dissolved again into the common mass of the people: longer periods would probably have produced danger; shorter, tumult, instability and inefficacy. Every article of these and other essentials to a republican government, are, in my opinion, well secured; were it otherwise, not a citizen of the United States would have been more alarmed, or more early in opposition to it, than

A steady and open Republican.

Charleston, May 2d, 1788.

[pg 415]

Bibliography.

[This list is only of those essays to which some clue of authorship has been found. When written over a pen name the pseudonym is added.—Ed.]

Brackenridge, Hugh Henry.
Pittsburg Gazette.

Bryan, Samuel. “Centinel.”
Independent Gazetteer.

Carroll, Daniel. “A Friend to the Constitution.”
Maryland Journal.

Chase, Samuel. “Caution.”
Maryland Journal.

Clinton, De Witt. “A Countryman.”
New York Journal.

Clinton, George. “Cato.”
New York Journal.

Coxe, Tench. “A Freeman.”
Pennsylvania Gazette.

Coxe, Tench. “An American.”
Independent Gazetteer.

Coxe, Tench. “A Pennsylvanian.”
Pennsylvania Gazette.

Duer, William. “Philo-Publius.”
Daily Advertiser.

Davie, William Richardson. “Publicola.”
North Carolina State Gazette.

Dickinson, John. “Fabius.”
Humphrey's Mercury.

Ellsworth, Oliver. “A Landholder.”
Connecticut Courant.

Findley, William. “An Officer of the Continental Army.”
Independent Gazetteer.

[pg 416]

Gerry, Elbridge.
Massachusetts Centinel.

Gerry, Elbridge.
American Herald.

Hamilton, Alexander. “Publius.”
Various papers.

Hamilton, Alexander. “CÆsar.”
Daily Advertiser.

Hanson, Alexander Contee. “Aristides.”
Maryland Journal.

Hopkinson, Francis. “A. B.”
Independent Gazetteer.

Iredell, James. “Marcus.”
North Carolina State Gazette.

Jay, John. “Publius.”
Various papers.

Lamb, John. “Conciliator.”
New York Journal.

McKnight, Dr. Charles. “The Examiner.”
Daily Advertiser.

Martin, Luther.
Maryland Journal.

Madison, James. “Publius.”
Various papers.

Nicholas, John. “Decius.”
Virginia Independent Chronicle.

Pinckney, Charles. “A Steady and Open Republican.”
State Gazette of South Carolina.

Randolph, Thomas Mann. “A Republican Federalist.”
Virginia Independent Chronicle.

Roane, Spencer. “A Plain Dealer.”
Virginia Independent Chronicle.

Sherman, Roger. “A Countryman.”
New Haven Gazette.

Sherman, Roger. “A Citizen of New Haven.”
New Haven Gazette.

Sullivan, James. “Cassius.”
Massachusetts Gazette.

[pg 417]

Tucker, St. George. “A State Soldier.”
Virginia Independent Chronicle.

Williams, William.
American Mercury.

Williamson, Hugh.
North Carolina State Gazette.

Winthrop, James. “Agrippa.”
Massachusetts Gazette.

Workman, Benjamin. “Philadelphiensis.”
Independent Gazetteer.

Yates, Robert. “Brutus.”
New York Journal.

Yates, Robert. “Sydney.”
New York Journal.

[pg 419]
f="@public@vhost@g@html@files@31891@31891-h@31891-h.html#Pg045" class="tei tei-ref pginternal" style="text-align: left">45;
of taxation, 235;
over territories, 43;
over trade, 61;
representation in, 151.
[pg 420]
Connecticut, 183, 355;
address to, 215;
constitution of, 148;
Courant, 135, 415;
convention, 178, 207;
legislature of, 219;
manufactures of, 202;
taxation in, 74, 148;
tribute to New York from, 180.
Constituents, instructions from, 28.
Constitution, a creation of power, 145, 147;
adequacy of, 35;
adopting clause of, 131, 184, 362;
advantages of, 21;
amendment of, 44, 100, 118, 200, 233, 251, 284, 334;
attempts to surprise the people with, 327;
character of opposers of, 11, 143;
comparison of, 339;
with constitution of N. Y., 297;
with English, 381;
consolidating tendencies of, 65, 69, 70, 158, 53, 104, 123, 127, 130, 137, 161, 172, 182, 186, 339, 341, 350, 416;
conciliating conduct of, 174;
hypocrisy of, 174;
objections to constitutions, 132;
remarks on, 150.
Goddard, William, 341.
Government, divisions of, 116;
encroaching tendencies of, 376;
General and State linked, 153;
Greek and Roman, 55;
importance, 247;
necessity of, to society, 111;
opposition to, 24;
a strong one necessary for liberty, 147.
Great Britain, dangers from, 190;
resentment of, 89.
Habeas corpus, suspension of, 36.
Hamilton, Alexander, 245, 279, 416.
Hampshire Gazette, 5.
Hancock, John, 3, 5, 10.
Hanson, Alexander Contee, 372, 416.
Hartford, 216.
Harvard College Library, 40.
Holland, public debt due, 73.
H 891@31891-h@31891-h.html#Pg299" class="tei tei-ref pginternal" style="text-align: left">299;
violation of, 301;
draft of a constitution for, 307;
impost of, 173;
opposition in, 176;
proposed property qualification in, 307;
State convention of 1776, 298;
State debt of, 60;
Executive, 310;
taxation in, 74;
tribute from Connecticut to, 180.
New York Journal, 125, 243, 269, 293, 415, 416, 417.
Nicholas, John, 416.
North Carolina, 258.
North Carolina, State Gazette of, 395, 415, 416, 417.
Northern States, character of people of, 92.
Nova Scotia, 191;
condition of, 89.
“Numa,” pseudonym of, 5, 10.
Oath, 207, 369;
character of, 17, 168;
of President, 38.
“Ocrico,” pseudonym of, 52.
Officers, federal, privileges of, 119.
Office holders, 145;
multiplication of, 88.
“Officer of the Continental Army,” pseudonym of, 66;
bills of right valid in federal courts, 119;
consolidation of, 97, 255;
destruction of, 375;
disputes between, 64, 100;
equality of, in Senate, 29;
interest of, 215;
large vs. small, 216, 355;
number to organize government, 184;
rights to enforce laws of, 118.
State Gazette of North Carolina, 395.
State Gazette of South Carolina, 416.
State house, 355.
“State Soldier,” pseudonym of, 417.
“Steady and Open Republican,” pseudonym of, 416.
“Steady,” pseudonym of, 326.
Strong, Caleb, 105.
Sullivan, James, 1, 416.
“Sydney,” pseudonym of, 269, 293, 417.
Tax, poll, 273.
Taxation, 156, 193;
dangers of, 81;
direct, 235, 270;
importance of, 271;
in Connecticut, 148, 226;
method of, 77, 358;
powers of Congress over, 97.
Tender acts, To prevent any misconstruction the following is the publication entire:

(This note is by the Landholder, and is followed by the article already printed at p. 127. It therefore seems unnecessary to add it here.—Ed.)

I will not say this writer makes a distinction between a thing done in convention and a thing done in committee. Be this as it may, he confesses more than Mr. Martin; for it seems that Mr. Gerry proposed that “the public debt should stand on the same ground it now stands on by the articles of confederation.” He might have subjoined that Mr. Gerry prefaced this motion by observing that it was the same in substance as his first, in as much as it included his first. But notwithstanding this motion was readily agreed to without his explanation being contradicted, yet he never afterwards favoured the convention with a look of peace, or a word of reconcilement.

50.
The convention of New Hampshire had met on the 13 of June, and after a discussion of seven days, had adjourned without voting upon the constitution.—Ed.
51.
See Letter of William Williams in this Collection.—Ed.
52.
This is a paraphrase of the arguments of “The Centinel” in The Independent Gazetteer.—Ed.
53.
An attempt had been made in Congress, by the friends of the new government, for Congress to recommend its acceptance, but this produced protest from those opposed to it, and threats of an appeal to the people, so in order to prevent such action a compromise was eventually made, by which it was merely unanimously “transmitted to the several legislatures.”Ed.
54.
A series of articles in the New York Journal, written by Robert Yates.—Ed.
55.
John Smilie, a prominent Anti-Federalist.—Ed.
56.
William Livingston.—Ed.
57.
See Ante, pages 182 and 189.—Ed.
58.
The Maryland Delegates to the Federal Convention were required by the legislature to report the proceedings of that body to them, and it was in this connection that Martin's Genuine Information was prepared.—Ed.
59.
According to this idea, I endeavored to obtain as an amendment to the system the following clause: “And whenever the legislature of the United States shall find it necessary that revenue shall be raised by direct taxation, having apportioned the same by the above rule, requisitions shall be made of the respective states to pay into the continental treasury their respective quotas within a time in the said requisition to be specified, and in case of any of the states failing to comply with such requisition, then, and then only, to have power to devise and pass acts directing the mode, and authorizing the same in the state failing therein.” This was rejected, and that power, which I wished to have given the government only in this particular instance, is given to it without any restraint or limitation in every case.
60.
How exactly agreeable to the sentiments of that honourable member has been the conduct of the friends of the Constitution in Pennsylvania and some other states, I need not mention.
61.
A reference to Alexander Contee Hanson's pamphlet, written under the pseudonym of Aristides. It is reprinted in Ford's Pamphlets on the Constitution.—Ed.
62.
Printed in Elliot, 1, 503.—Ed.
63.
Williamson was a member of the Federal Convention.—Ed.
64.
Following this article was an essay from a New York paper.—Ed.
65.
See page 339.—Ed.

***END OF THE PROJECT GUTENBERG EBOOK ESSAYS ON THE CONSTITUTION OF THE UNITED STATES***


A Word from Project Gutenberg

This and all associated files of various formats will be found in: /dirs/3/1/8/9/31891/

Updated editions will replace the previous one — the old editions will be renamed.

Please read this before you distribute or use this work.

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           

Clyx.com


Top of Page
Top of Page