Scene 1. Page 21. Buck. ... but this top-proud fellow (Whom from the flow of gall I name not, but From sincere motions) Dr. Johnson explains sincere motions to be honest indignation; and, for name not, would substitute blame not. But is not the following the plain sense, without any alteration? "this top-proud fellow, whom I call so, not from an excess of bitterness, but from a genuine impulse of the mind." Scene 1. Page 26. Buck. I am the shadow of poor Buckingham, Whose figure even this instant cloud puts on, By dark'ning my clear sun. It is no easy matter on some occasions to comprehend the precise meaning of Shakspeare's metaphors, which are often careless and confused; and of this position the present lines are, doubtless, an example. We have here a double comparison. Buckingham is first made to say that he is but a shadow; in other terms, a dead man. He then adverts to the sudden cloud of misfortune that overwhelms him, and, like a shadow, obscures his prosperity. Scene 3. Page 42. Cham. Is it possible the spells of France should juggle Men into such strange mysteries? Dr. Johnson's explanation is much too fanciful. Mysteries are arts, and here artificial fashions. ACT II.Scene 2. Page 71. Nor. I'll venture one heave at him. The first folio reads "I'll venture one; have at him," and this, except as to the punctuation, is right. Have at you was a common phrase; it is used by Surrey in the ensuing act, and afterwards by Cromwell. Scene 2. Page 73. Cam. ... which so griev'd him, [Doctor Pace] That he ran mad and died. This is from Holinshed. "Aboute this time the king received into favor doctor Stephen Gardiner, whose service he used in matters of great secrecie and weighte, admitting him in the room of Doctor Pace, the which being continually abrode in ambassades, and the same oftentymes not much necessarie, by the Cardinalles appointment, at length he toke such greefe therwith, that he fell out of his right wittes." Scene 3. Page 75. Anne. ... 'tis a sufferance panging As soul and body's severing. Of the parallel passages already cited, this is not the least so, from Measure for measure; "... in corporal sufferance feels a pang as great As when a giant dies." Scene 4. Page 98. [they rise to depart. Mr. Ridley's note is very judiciously introduced to get rid of the interpolated stage direction inserted by some of the editors, and to account for the king's apostrophe to Cranmer. He might have adduced an earlier exemplification of his remark from the ensuing scene, where Norfolk asks, when Cranmer returns? The archbishop of Canterbury, who attends the procession to Blackfriars, was William Warham. ACT III.Scene 2. Page 112. Suf. ... I persuade me, from her Will fall some blessing to this land, which shall In it be memoriz'd. This is, no doubt, a compliment to queen Elizabeth. Scene 2. Page 126. Sur. ... I'll startle you Worse than the sacring bell, when the brown wench Lay kissing in your arms, lord cardinal. Was there any Skeltonical tradition to this effect in Shakspeare's time, or has he only taken a hint from one of the articles against Wolsey, which is conceived in the following terms? "Also the said Lord Cardinall did call before him Sir John Stanly knight which had taken a farm by Covent seal of the Abbot of Chester and afterwards by his power and might contrary to right committed the said Sir John Stanly to the prison of Fleet by the space of a year unto such time as he compelled the said Sir John to release his Covent seal to one Leghe of Adlington, which married one Lark's daughter, which woman the said Lord Cardinall kept, and had with her two children," &c. Scene 2. Page 127. Sur. First, that, without the king's assent, or knowledge, You wrought to be a legate; by which power You maim'd the jurisdiction of all bishops. We have here in substance the first of the articles exhibited by the lords of the privy council and two of the judges against Wolsey. They had been unfaithfully recorded in some of our histories, but were at length printed by Lord Coke from the originals in his fourth Institute, chap. 8. Scene 2. Page 127. Nor. Then, that, in all you writ to Rome, or else To foreign princes, Ego et rex meus Was still inscrib'd; in which you brought the king To be your servant. The nature of this supposed offence has been apparently Scene 2. Page 128. Suf. Then that without the knowledge Either of king or council, when you went Ambassador to the emperor, you made bold To carry into Flanders the great seal. Sur. Item, you sent a large commission To Gregory de Cassalis, to conclude, Without the king's will, or the state's allowance, A league between his highness and Ferrara. Both these charges seem included in the third article. "Also the said Lord Cardinall being your ambassador in France, sent a commission to Sir Gregory de Cassalis under your great seale in your grace's name to conclude a treaty of amity with the Duke of Ferrara, without any commandment or warrant of your highnes, nor your said highnesse advertised or made privy to the same." Scene 2. Page 129. Suf. That out of mere ambition you have caus'd Your holy hat to be stamp'd on the king's coin. An absurd and frivolous allegation against the unfortunate Cardinal, being the substance of the fortieth article. The episcopal privileges of coining money had been long esta Scene 2. Page 129. Suf. Lord Cardinal, the king's further pleasure is,— Because all those things, you have done of late By your power legatine within this kingdom, Fall into the compass of a prÆmunire,— That therefore such a writ be sued against you. The poet was under the necessity of introducing the prÆmunire immediately after the articles; but we learn from Cavendish that "Maister Cromwell inveighed against the byll of articles with such wittie persuasions and depe reasons that the same could take none effect. Then were his enemyes constrained to indite him in a PREMUNIRE," &c. Scene 2. Page 131. Wol. And when he falls, he falls like Lucifer. Manifestly borrowed from that fine passage in Isaiah, xiv. ver. 12: "How art thou fallen from heaven, O Lucifer, son of the morning!" Scene 2. Page 135. Wol. And sleep in dull cold marble. Mr. Gray seems to have remembered this line in his elegy,— "Or flattery sooth the dull cold ear of death." Scene 2. Page 137. Wol. Had I but serv'd my God with half the zeal I serv'd my king, he would not in mine age Have left me naked to mine enemies. Dr. Johnson remarks, that "this sentence was really uttered by Wolsey." The substance of it certainly was. The words themselves have been preserved in the valuable Life of Wolsey by George Cavendish his gentleman usher, which Shakspeare might have used either in Stowe's chronicle or in manuscript; for several copies are still remaining that were transcribed in the reign of Elizabeth. Mr. Malone has already taken due notice of their very superior value, and of the omissions and interpolations in the printed editions. In the latter, the work has been abridged of many details of great curiosity with respect to the manners of the times. A new and correct edition would be well deserving of the patronage of an enlightened public. The real words uttered by Wolsey were these; "Yf I hadd served God as diligently as I have done the kinge, he wolde not have geven me over in my graye heares." ACT V.Scene 3. Page 193. Man. ... and hit that woman, who cry'd out, Clubs! It has been observed, in illustration of this practice of crying out clubs, that it was usually adopted in any quarrel or tumult in the streets; but it remains to point out the persons that were so called, because the watchmen's weapon was the bill. Stowe informs us, that "when prentizes and journeymen attended upon their masters and mistresses in the night, they went before them carrying a lanthorne and candle in their hands, and a great long club on their neckes."—Annales, p. 1040, edit. 1631. The frequency of this exclamation in Scene 4. Page 199. It is submitted that the stage exhibition of Elizabeth's christening should be conducted according to the curious and circumstantial details of the manner in which it was really performed, to be found in Halle's Chronicle, and copied from him by Stowe into his Annales. |