I. APPARATUS.1. Sample Bottles.—Any size, shape or quality of bottle may be used for a bacterial sample, provided it holds a sufficient amount to carry out all the tests required and is such that it may be properly washed and sterilized and will keep the sample uncontaminated until the analysis is made. Four- or eight-ounce, ground-glass-stoppered bottles are recommended. These should be protected by being wrapped in paper, or their necks covered with tin foil, and should be placed in proper boxes for transportation. 2. Pipettes.—Pipettes may be of any convenient size or shape provided it is found by actual test that they deliver accurately the required amount in the manner in which they are used. The error of calibration shall in no case exceed 2 per cent. Protecting the pipettes with a cotton stopper is recommended. 3. Dilution Bottles.—Bottles for use in making dilutions should preferably be of tall form, of such capacity as to hold at least twice the volume of water actually used. Close-fitting ground-glass stoppers are preferable, but tight fitting cotton stoppers may be used, provided due care is taken to prevent contamination and to avoid loss of volume through wetting of the stopper before mixing has been accomplished. 4. Petri Dishes.—Petri dishes ten centimeters in diameter shall be used with glass or porous tops 5. Fermentation Tubes.—Any type of fermentation tube II. MATERIALS. 1. Water.—Distilled water shall be used in the preparation of all culture media and reagents. 2. Meat Extract.—Liebig’s meat extract shall be used in place of meat infusion. Other brands may be substituted for Liebig’s when comparative tests have shown that they give equivalent results. 3. Peptone.—Armour’s, Digestive Ferments Company’s, Fairchild’s, or any other peptone which gives equivalent results may be used. 4. Sugars.—All sugars used shall be of the highest purity obtainable. 5. Agar.—The agar used shall be of the best quality and shall be dried for one-half hour at 105° C. before weighing. Much of the agar on the market contains considerable amounts of sea salts. 6. Gelatin.—The gelatin used shall be of light color, shall contain not more than a trace of arsenic, copper, sulfides, and shall be free from preservatives, and of such a melting point that a 10 per cent. standard nutrient gelatin shall have a melting point of 25° C. or over. Gelatin shall be dried for one-half hour at 105° C. before weighing. 7. Litmus.—Reagent litmus of highest purity (not litmus cubes) or azolitmin (Kahlbaum) shall be used for all media requiring a litmus indicator. 8. General Chemicals.—Special effort shall be made to have all the other ingredients used for culture media chemically pure. III. METHODS. 1. PREPARATION OF CULTURE MEDIA.a. Adjustment of Reaction.aa. Phenol Red Method for adjustment to a hydrogen-ion concentration of PH+ = 6.8–8.4. Withdraw 5 cc. of the medium, dilute with 5 cc. of distilled water, and add 5 drops of a solution of phenol red (phenol sulphone phthalein). This solution is made by dissolving 0.04 grams of phenol red in 30 cc. of alcohol and diluting to 100 cc. with distilled water. Titrate with a 1:10 dilution of a standard solution of NaOH (which need not be of known normality) until the phenol red shows a slight but distinct pink color. Calculate the amount of the standard NaOH solution which must be added to the medium to reach bb. Titration with phenolphthalein. (For the convenience of those who wish to retain the use of this method for the present it is given here, but it is recommended that as soon as possible the more accurate method of determining the hydrogen-ion concentration be substituted.) In a white porcelain dish put 5 cc. of the medium to be tested, add 45 cc. of distilled water. Boil briskly for one minute. Add 1 cc. of phenolphthalein solution (5 grams of commercial salt to one liter of 50 per cent. alcohol). Titrate immediately with a n/20 solution of sodium hydrate. A faint but distinct pink color marks the true end-point. This color may be precisely described as a combination of 25 per cent. of red (wave length approximately 658) with 75 per cent. of white as shown by the disks of the standard color top made by the Milton Bradley Educational Co., Springfield, Mass. All reactions shall be expressed with reference to the phenolphthalein neutral point and shall be stated in percentages of normal acid or alkali solutions required to neutralize them. Alkaline media shall be recorded with a minus (-) sign before the percentage of normal acid needed for their neutralization and acid media with a plus (+) sign before the percentage of normal alkali solution needed for their neutralization. The standard reaction for culture media for water analysis shall be +1.0 per cent., as determined by tests of the sterilized medium. As ordinarily prepared, broth and agar will be found to have a reaction between +0.5 and +1.0. For such media no adjustment shall be made. The reaction of media containing sugar shall be neutral to phenolphthalein. Whenever reactions other than the standard are used, it shall be so stated. b. Sterilization.All media and dilution water shall be sterilized in the autoclav at 15 lbs. (120° C.) for 15 minutes after the pressure reaches 15 lbs. All air must be forced out of the autoclav before the pressure is allowed to rise. As soon as possible after sterilization the media shall be removed from the autoclav and cooled rapidly. Rapid and immediate cooling of gelatin is imperative. Media shall be sterilized in small containers, and these must not be closely packed together. No part of the medium shall be more c. Nutrient Broth. To Make One Liter.1. Add 3 grams of beef extract and 5 grams of peptone to 1,000 cc. of distilled water. 2. Heat slowly on a steam bath to at least 65° C. 3. Make up lost weight and adjust the reaction to a faint pink with phenol red, or if the phenolphthalein titration is used, and the reaction is not already between +0.5 and +1, adjust to +1. 4. Cool to 25° C. and filter through filter paper until clear. 5. Distribute in test-tubes, 10 cc. to each tube. 6. Sterilize in the autoclav at 15 lbs. (120° C.) for 15 minutes after the pressure reaches 15 lbs. d. Sugar Broths.Sugar broths shall be prepared in the same general manner as nutrient broth with the addition of 0.5 per cent. of the required carbohydrate just before sterilization. The removal of muscle sugar is unnecessary as the beef extract and peptone are free from any fermentable carbohydrates. The reaction of sugar broths shall be a faint pink with phenol red or, if on titration with phenolphthalein the reaction is not already between neutral and +1, adjust to neutral. Sterilization shall be in the autoclav at 15 lbs. (120° C.) for 15 minutes after the pressure reaches 15 lbs., provided the total time of exposure to heat is not more than one-half hour; otherwise a 10 per cent. solution of the required carbohydrate shall be made in distilled water and sterilized at 100° C. for 1½ hours, and this solution shall be added to sterile nutrient broth in amounts sufficient to make a 0.5 per cent. solution of the carbohydrate and the mixture shall then be tubed and sterilized at 100° C. for 30 minutes, or it is permissible to add by means of a sterile pipette directly to a tube of sterile neutral broth enough of the carbohydrate to make the required 0.5 per cent. The tubes so made shall be incubated at 37° C. for 24 hours as a test for sterility. e. Nutrient Gelatin. To Make One Liter.1. Add 3 grams of beef extract and 5 grams of peptone to 1,000 cc. of distilled water and add 100 grams of gelatin dried for one-half hour at 105° C. before weighing. G. The solution of the gelatin will be facilitated by allowing it to soak in the cold one-half hour before heating. 3. Make up lost weight and adjust the reaction to a faint pink with phenol red, or if the phenolphthalein titration is used, and the reaction is not already between +0.5 and +1, adjust to +1. 4. Filter through cloth and cotton until clear. 5. Distribute in test-tubes, 10 cc. to each tube, or in larger containers as desired. 6. Sterilize in the autoclav at 15 lbs. (120° C.) for 15 minutes after the pressure reaches 15 lbs. f. Nutrient Agar. To Make One Liter.1. Add 3 grams of beef extract, 5 grams of peptone and 12 grams of agar, dried for one-half hour at 105° C. before weighing, to 1,000 cc. of distilled water. Boil over a water bath until all agar is dissolved, and then make up the loss by evaporation. 2. Cool to 45° C. in a cold water bath, then warm to 65° C. in the same bath, without stirring. 3. Make up lost weight and adjust the reaction to a faint pink with phenol red, or if the phenolphthalein titration is used, and the reaction is not already between +0.5 and +1, adjust to +1. 4. Filter through cloth and cotton until clear. 5. Distribute in test-tubes, 10 cc. to each tube, or in larger containers, as desired. 6. Sterilize in the autoclav at 15 lbs. (120° C.) for 15 minutes after the pressure reaches 15 lbs. g. Litmus or Azolitmin Solution.The standard litmus solution shall be a 2 per cent. aqueous solution of reagent litmus. Powder the litmus, add to the water and boil for five minutes. The solution usually needs no correction in reaction and may be at once distributed in flasks or test-tubes and sterilized as is culture media. It should give a distinctly blue plate when 1 cc. is added to 10 cc. of neutral culture medium in a Petri dish. The standard azolitmin solution shall be a 1 per cent. solution of Kahlbaum’s azolitmin. Add the azolitmin powder to the water and boil for five minutes. The solution may need to be corrected in reaction by the addition of sodium hydrate solution so that it will be approximately neutral and will give a distinctly blue plate h. Litmus-lactose-agar.Litmus-lactose-agar shall be prepared in the same manner as nutrient agar with the addition of 1 per cent. of lactose just before sterilization. The reaction shall be a faint pink with phenol red, or, if on titration with phenolphthalein the reaction is not already between neutral and +1, adjust to neutral. One cc. of sterilized litmus or azolitmin solution shall be added to each 10 cc. of the medium just before it is poured into the Petri dish, or the mixture may be made in the dish itself. i. Endo’s Medium. |
Number of bacteria per cc. | |||||
From | 1 | to | 50 | shall be recorded as found | |
? | 51 | ? | 100 | ? ? ? to the nearest | 5 |
? | 101 | ? | 250 | ? ? ? ? ? ? | 10 |
? | 251 | ? | 500 | ? ? ? ? ? ? | 25 |
? | 501 | ? | 1,000 | ? ? ? ? ? ? | 50 |
? | 1,001 | ? | 10,000 | ? ? ? ? ? ? | 100 |
? | 10,001 | ? | 50,000 | ? ? ? ? ? ? | 500 |
? | 50,001 | ? | 100,000 | ? ? ? ? ? ? | 1,000 |
? | 100,001 | ? | 500,000 | ? ? ? ? ? ? | 10,000 |
? | 500,001 | ? | 1,000,000 | ? ? ? ? ? ? | 50,000 |
? | 1,000,001 | ? | 10,000,000 | ? ? ? ? ? ? | 100,000 |
This applies to the gelatin count at 20° C. and to the agar count at 37° C.
Summary of steps involved in making presumptive, partially confirmed and completed tests for b. coli.
Steps in procedure. | Further procedure required. | ||
---|---|---|---|
I. Inoculate lactose broth fermentation tubes; incubate 24 hours at 37° C.; observe gas-formation in each tube. | |||
1. Gas-formation, 10 per cent. or more; constitutes positive presumptive test. | |||
(a) For other than smallest portion of any sample showing gas at this time, and for all portions, including smallest, of sewage and raw water this test is sufficient. | None | ||
(b) For smallest gas-forming portion, except in examinations of sewage and raw water. | III | ||
2. Gas-formation less than 10 per cent. in 24 hours; inconclusive. | II | ||
II. Incubate an additional 24 hours, making a total of 48 hours’ incubation; observe gas-formation. | |||
1. Gas-formation, any amount; constitutes doubtful test, which must always be carried further. | III | ||
2. No gas-formation in 48 hours; constitutes final negative test. | None | ||
III. Make plate from smallest gas-forming portion of sample under examination; incubate 18 to 24 hours; observe colonies. | |||
1. One or more colonies typical in appearance. | |||
(a) If only “partially confirmed” test is required | None | ||
(b) If completed test is required, select two typical colonies for identification. | V | ||
2. No typical colonies. | IV | ||
IV. Replace plate in incubator for an additional 18 to 24 hours; then, whether colonies appear typical or not, select at least two of those which most nearly resemble B. coli. | V | ||
V. Transfer each colony fished to: | |||
1. Lactose broth fermentation tube; incubate not more than 48 hours at 37° C. Observe gas-formation. | None | ||
2. Agar slant; incubate 48 hours at 37° C. | |||
(a) If gas formed in lactose broth tube inoculated with corresponding culture | VI | ||
(b) If no gas formed in corresponding lactose broth tube, test is completed and negative. | None | ||
VI. Make stained cover-slip or slide preparation, and examine microscopically. | |||
1. If preparation shows non-spore-forming bacilli in apparently pure culture, demonstration of B. coli is completed. | None | ||
2. If preparation fails to show non-spore-forming bacilli or shows them mixed with spore-bearing forms or bacteria of other morphology. | VII | ||
VII. Replate, to obtain assuredly pure culture, select several colonies of bacilli and repeat steps V and VI. |
Ordinarily not less than three portions of each sample should be tested, the portions being even decimal multiples or fractions of a cubic centimeter; for example, 10 cc., 1 cc., 0.1 cc., .01 cc., etc. It is essential that the dilutions should be such that the largest amount gives a positive test (unless the water is such as to give negative tests in 10 cc.), and the smallest dilution, a negative result. To insure this result, it is often necessary to plant four or five dilutions, especially in the examination of a sample of entirely unknown quality. The quantitative value of a series of tests is lost, unless all or at least a large proportion of the smallest dilutions tested have given negative results.
In reporting a single test, it is preferable merely to record results as observed, indicating the amounts tested and the result in each, rather than to attempt expression of the result in numbers of B. coli per cc. In summarizing the results of a series of tests, however, it is desirable, for the sake of simplicity, to express the results in terms of the numbers of B. coli per cc., or per 100 cc. To convert results of fermentation tests to this form, the result of each test is recorded as indicating a number of B. coli per cc. equal to the reciprocal of the smallest decimal or multiple fraction of a cubic centimeter giving a positive result. For example, the result: 10 cc. +; 1 cc. +; 0.1 cc. -; would be recorded as indicating one B. coli per cc. An exception should be made in the case where a negative result is obtained in an amount larger than the smallest portion giving a positive result; for example, in a result such as: 10 cc. +; 1 cc. -; 0.1 cc. +. In such case, the result should be recorded as indicating a number of B. coli per cc. equal to the reciprocal of the dilution next larger than the smallest one giving a positive test, this being a more probable result.
Where tests are made in amounts larger than 1 cc., giving average results less than one B. coli per cc., it is more convenient to express results in terms of the numbers of B. coli per 100 cc.
The following table illustrates the method of recording and averaging results of B. coli tests:
Result of Tests in Amounts Designated. | Indicated Number of B. coli. | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
10 cc. | 1 cc. | 0.1 cc. | .01 cc. | per cc. | per 100 cc. |
+ | - | - | - | 0.1 | 10. |
+ | + | - | - | 1.0 | 100. |
+ | + | + | - | 10.0 | 1,000. |
+ | + | + | + | 100.0 | 10,000. |
+ | + | - | + | 10.0 | 1,000. |
| | ||||
Totals (for estimating averages) | 121.1 | 12,110. | |||
Average of 5 tests | 24.0 | 2,422. |
The above method of expressing results is not mathematically altogether correct. The average number of B. coli per cc., as thus estimated, is not precisely the most probable number calculated by application of the theory of probability.
In order that results as reported may be checked and carefully valuated, it is necessary that the report should show not only the average number of B. coli per cc., but also the number of samples examined; and, for each dilution, the total number of tests made, and the number (or per cent.) positive.
10. INTERPRETATION OF RESULTS.
While it is not within the province of this report to suggest the proper interpretation of results obtained by the use of the methods herein specified as standard, the committee feels that a word of caution should be given regarding the significance of the presence in a water of members of the B. coli group as defined in this report. Recent work seems to indicate that the B. coli group as herein defined consists of organisms of both fecal and non-fecal origin. Therefore care must be exercised in judging the sanitary quality of a water solely from the determination of the presence of members of the group.
11. DIFFERENTIATION OF FECAL FROM NON-FECAL MEMBERS OF THE B. COLI GROUP.
(1) At least 10 cultures should be used. If possible these should be subcultured from plates made direct from the water since all of the cultures obtained by plating from fermentation tubes may be
(2) Inoculate each culture into dextrose potassium phosphate broth,
H. (a) Peptone Medium for the Methyl Red Test. To Make One Liter.
1. To 800 cc. of distilled water add 5 grams of Proteose-Peptone, Difco., or Witte’s Peptone (other peptones should not be substituted), 5 grams c. p. dextrose, and 5 grams dipotassium hydrogen phosphate (K2HPO4). A dilute solution of the K2HPO4 should give a distinct pink with phenolphthalein.
2. Heat with occasional stirring over steam for twenty minutes.
3. Filter through folded filter paper, cool to 20° C. and dilute to 1,000 cc. with distilled water.
4. Distribute 10 cc. portions in sterilized test-tubes.
5. Sterilize by the intermittent method for 20 minutes on three successive days.
I. Tryptophane Broth for Indol Test.
To 1,000 cc. of distilled water add 0.3 gram tryptophane, 5 grams dipotassium hydrogen phosphate (K2HPO4), and 1 gram peptone. Heat until ingredients are thoroughly dissolved, tube (6 to 8 cc.), and sterilize in autoclave for 15 minutes after the pressure reaches 15 pounds. Some American peptones are standardized to contain a uniform amount of tryptophane. If such peptone is used the tryptophane in the above formula may be omitted and the peptone increased to 5 grams.
(3) After 48 hours record gas formation in adonite and saccharose broths. Determine indol formation in tryptophane broth by adding drop by drop, to avoid mixing with the medium, about 1 cc. of a 2 per cent. alcoholic solution of p-dimethyl amido-benzaldehyd, then a few drops of concentrated hydrochloric acid. The presence of indol is indicated by a red color which is soluble in chloroform. There may be some unconverted tryptophane still present which will give a distinctly blue color which is insoluble in chloroform. A mixture of the two will be either blue or violet. If from such a mixture of colors the red of indol be extracted with chloroform proof of the presence of indol will be complete.
(4) After 5 days apply methyl red test and Voges-Proskauer test to dextrose broth.
Methyl Red Test. [J]
Indicator solution.—Dissolve 0.1 gram methyl red in 300 cc. alcohol and dilute to 500 cc. with distilled water.
J. (b) Synthetic Medium for the Methyl Red Test. To Make One Liter. Dissolve 7 grams Na2HPO4 (anhydrous) or 8.8 grams Na2HPO4.2H2O, 2 grams KHphthalate, 1 gram aspartic acid, and 4 grams dextrose in about 800 cc. of warm distilled water. When solution is complete, cool and make up to 1 liter at room temperature. Heat in an autoclave for 15 minutes after the pressure has reached 15 pounds, provided the total time of exposure to heat is not more than one-half hour. The hydrogen-ion concentration of the medium is fixed by the composition. It should be very close to PH 7.0, slightly red with phenol red. All materials should be recrystallized or if used from stock furnished by manufacturers, should be carefully examined. The di-sodium hydrogen phosphate may be used either as the anhydrous salt obtained by dessication in vacuo at 100° C. or else as the salt containing two molecules of water of crystallization. This is obtained by exposing the recrystallized Na2HPO4.12H2O for two weeks. Use 0.88 per cent. of Na2HPO4.2H2O.
Procedure in test.—1. To 5 cc. of each culture add 5 drops of methyl red solution.
Voges-Proskauer Test. [216]
To the remaining 5 cc. of medium add 5 cc. of a 10 per cent. solution of potassium hydroxide. Allow to stand over night. A positive test is indicated by an eosin pink color.
(5) Gelatin tubes should not be pronounced negative until they have been incubated at least 15 days.
The following group reactions indicate the source of the culture with a high degree of probability:
Methyl red + | B. coli of fecal origin. |
Voges-Proskauer - | |
Gelatin - | |
Adonite - | |
Indol, usually + | |
Saccharose, usually - | |
Methyl red - | B. aËrogenes of fecal origin. |
Voges-Proskauer + | |
Gelatin - | |
Adonite + | |
Indol, usually - | |
Saccharose + | |
Methyl red - | B. aËrogenes, probably not of fecal origin. |
Voges-Proskauer + | |
Gelatin - | |
Adonite - | |
Indol, usually - | |
Saccharose + | |
Methyl red - | B. cloacae, may or may not be of fecal origin. |
Voges-Proskauer + | |
Gelatin + | |
Adonite + | |
Indol, usually - | |
Saccharose + |
12. ROUTINE PROCEDURE FOR EXAMINATION OF SAMPLES OF WATER.
First Day:
1. Prepare dilutions as required.
2. Make two (2) gelatin plates from each dilution, and incubate at 20° C.
3. Make two (2) agar plates from each dilution, and incubate at 37° C.
Note:—Where repeated tests are made of water from the same source, as is customary in the control of public supplies, it is not necessary to make duplicate plates or fermentation tubes in each dilution. It is sufficient, in such circumstances, to make duplicate plates only from the dilution which will most probably give from 25 to 250 colonies per plate.
Second Day:
1. Count the agar plates made on the first day.
2. Record the number of lactose broth fermentation tubes which show 10 per cent. (10%) or more of gas.
Note:—In case only the presumptive test for B. coli is required, fermentation tubes showing more than 10 per cent. (10%) of gas at this time may be discarded.
Third Day:
1. Count gelatin plates made on first day.
2. Record the number of additional fermentation tubes which show 10 per cent. (10%) or more of gas.
3. Make a lactose-litmus-agar or Endo’s medium plate from the smallest portion of each sample showing gas. Incubate plate at 37° C.
Note:—In case the smallest portion in which gas has been formed shows less than 10 per cent. (10%) of gas, it is well to make a plate also from the next larger portion, so that, in case the smallest portion gives a negative end result it may still be possible to demonstrate B. coli in the next larger dilution.
Fourth Day:
1. Examine Endo’s medium or lactose-litmus-agar plates. If typical colonies have developed, select two and transfer each to a lactose broth fermentation tube and an agar slant, both of which are to be incubated at 37° C.
2. If no typical B. coli colonies are found, incubate the plates another 24 hours.
Fifth Day:
1. Select at least two colonies, whether typical or not, from the Endo’s medium or lactose-litmus-agar plates which have been incubated an additional 24 hours; transfer each to a lactose
2. Examine lactose broth fermentation tubes inoculated from plates on the previous day. Tubes in which gas has been formed may be discarded after the result has been recorded. Those in which no gas has formed should be incubated an additional 24 hours.
Sixth Day:
1. Examine lactose broth fermentation tubes reincubated the previous day.
2. Examine microscopically agar slants corresponding to lactose fermentation tubes inoculated from plate colonies and showing gas-formation.
BACTERIOLOGICAL BIBLIOGRAPHY.
201. Bovie, W. T. A Direct Reading Potentiometer for Measuring and Recording both the Actual and the Total Reaction of Solutions. Jour. Med. Research, 33, 1915–16, 295.
202. Breed, R. S. and Dotterrer, W. D. The Number of Colonies Allowable on Satisfactory Agar Plates. Jour. of Bact., 1, 1916, 321.
203. Browne, W. W. A Comparative Study of the Smith Fermentation Tube and the Inverted Vial in the Determination of Sugar Fermentation. Amer. Jour. of Public Health, 3, 1913, 701.
204. Clark, W. M. An Hydrogen Electrode Vessel. Jour. Biol. Chem., 23, 1915, 475.
205. Clark, W. M. The “Reaction” of Bacteriological Culture Media. Jour. of Inf. Diseases, 17, 1915, 109.
206. Clark, W. M. The Final Hydrogen Ion Concentrations of Cultures of Bacillus Coli. Science, n. s. 42, 1915, 71.
207. Clark, W. M. and Lubs, H. A. Hydrogen Electrode Potentials of Phthalate, Phosphate, and Borate Buffer Mixtures. Jour. Biol. Chem., 25, 1916, 479.
208. Clark, W. M. and Lubs, H. A. The Differentiation of Bacteria of the Colon-AËrogenes Family by the Use of Indicators. Jour. of Inf. Diseases, 17, 1915, 160.
209. Endo, S. Ueber ein Verfahren zum Nachweis der Typhusbacillen Centbl. f. Bakt. Erste Abt., 35, 1903–4, 109.
210. Gillespie, L. J. The Reaction of Soil and Measurements of Hydrogen Ion Concentration. Jour. Wash. Acad. of Sciences, 6, 1916, 7.
211. Hill, H. W. Porous Tops for Petri Dishes. Jour. Med. Research, 13, 1904, 93.
212. Hill, H. W. The Mathematics of the Bacterial Count. Public Health Reports and Papers, 33, 1907, 110.
213. Itano, A. The Relation of Hydrogen Ion Concentration of Media to the Proteolytic Activity of Bacillus Subtilis. Bulletin 167, 1916, Mass. Agric. Ex. Station.
214.
215. Kinyoun, J. J. and Deiter, L. V. On the Preparation of Endo’s Medium. Amer. Jour. Public Health, n. s. 2, 1912, 979.
216. Levine, M. On the Significance of the Voges-Proskauer Reaction. Jour. of Bacteriology, 1, 1916, 153.
217. Lubs, H. A. and Clark, W. M. On Some New Indicators for the Colorimetric Determination of Hydrogen-ion Concentration. Jour. Wash. Acad. of Sciences, 5, 1915, 609.
218. McClendon, J. F. New Hydrogen Electrodes and Rapid Methods of Determining Hydrogen Ion Concentrations. Amer. Jour. of Physiology, 38, 1915, 180.
219. McClendon, J. F. A Direct Reading Potentiometer for Measuring Hydrogen Ion Concentrations. Amer. Jour. of Physiology, 38, 1915, 186.
220. McCrady, M. H. The Numerical Interpretation of Fermentation-tube Results. Jour. Inf. Diseases, 17, 1915, 183.
221. Noyes, H. A. Agar Agar for Bacteriological Use. Science, n. s. 44, 1916, 797.
222. Rogers, L. A., Clark, W. M. and Davis, B. J. The Colon Group of Bacteria. Jour. of Inf. Diseases, 14, 1914, 411.
223. Rogers, L. A., Clark, W. M. and Evans, A. C. The Characteristics of Bacteria of the Colon Type Found in Bovine Feces. Jour. of Inf. Diseases, 15, 1914, 99.
224. Rogers, L. A., Clark, W. M. and Evans, A. C. The Characteristics of Bacteria of the Colon Type Occurring on Grains. Jour. of Inf. Diseases, 17, 1915, 137.
225. Smith, H. M. The Seaweed Industries of Japan. Bulletin of the Bureau of Fisheries, 24, 1904, 135.
226. SÖrensen, S. P. L. Enzymstudien. Biochem. Ztschr., 21, 1909, 131 and 201.
227. Whipple, G. C. On the Necessity of Cultivating Water Bacteria in an Atmosphere Saturated with Moisture. Tech. Quart., 12, 1899, 276.
228. Whittaker, H. A. The Source, Manufacture and Composition of Commercial Agar-agar. Jour. Amer. Pub. Health Assoc., n. s. 1, 1911, 632.
229. Clark, W. M. and Lubs, H. A. The colorimetric determination of the hydrogen-ion concentration of bacteriological culture media. Jour. Wash. Acad. Sciences, 6, 1916, 483.
230. Clark, W. M. and Lubs, H. A. The colorimetric determination of hydrogen-ion concentration and its application in bacteriology. Jour. of Bact., 2, 1919, 1 and 109.
231. Cohen, B. and Clark, W. M. The growth of certain bacteria in media of different hydrogen-ion concentrations. Jour. of Bact., 4, 1919, 409.
232. Fennel, E. A. and Fisher, M. A. Adjustment of culture medium reactions. Jour. of Inf. Diseases, 25, 1919, 444.
233. Jones, H. M. A rapid hydrogen-ion electrode method for the determination of hydrogen-ion concentrations in bacterial cultures or other turbid or colored solutions. Jour. of Inf. Diseases, 25, 1919, 262.