“Geography locates actual mountains, Rivers, and valleys, while critics Of literature and art Draw imaginary maps Small as the nail of an infant’s thumb. Then nouns and adjectives Are purchased and arranged To magnify and defend the size Of exquisite differences In altitude, position, and direction. Trivially vociferous, Your geographical critics Display their little maps to men Whose eyes are already convinced Or turned in another direction.” Torban, a scholar from Mars, Dropped his speech and laughed. His laugh was the sound of a mountain Emancipated by humour And cavorting over the plains. The mountain fled, but Torban remained, Made gigantic by its aftermath. For size does not reside In the legs and torsos That men hug, frightened, or with glee. He said: “Criticism in Mars Resembles your hours of sleep. Each night we leave creation; Greet the steeply slanting beds; And turn our large eyes inward To a complicated cabaret: Cabaret filled with relieving jigs; Cabaret crammed with irascible magicians Who persist in spoiling their little tricks By proclaiming the honesty of their intentions; Cabaret in which malice, Dignified or torrential, Turns creators into beetles And slays them ingeniously; Cabaret in which Erudition, Tempted by emotional coquettes, Swaggers greyly past the footlights; Cabaret in which Lust Defends itself with thoughtful monologues, Stopping to expectorate Into metaphysical cuspidors; Cabaret in which the mind Scorns the morphine of emotion Until, exhausted, it is forced Secretly to indulge in the drug; That lisp like market-women At an ancient Fair; Cabaret in which Tolerance and Indifference Sit on the floor below the banquet-table And wait for crumbs that accidentally Slip from the over-full plates; Cabaret in which Logic Swallows the whiskey of dogmas, Reels to the little bed-chamber, And gradually falls asleep; Cabaret in which qualities, Enlarged and beribboned, engage In arguments with smaller qualities, Each longing for the other’s size.” Torban paused, and his smile, A thread of quicksilver bettering his face, Encouraged the purpose of my voice. I said: “The cabaret that you describe Reminds me of criticism on earth.” He answered: “One difference exists. We go to sleep before we criticize— An excellent antidote for truth and lies!” |